... ...

Milwaukee’s Beast: American Idol 10 auditions are still airing

2011 January 26

Steven Tyler and Jennifer Lopez on American Idol in Milwaukee

As Thursday’s episode in New Orleans did not record and Wednesday’s began late for me last week, this is the first time I’ve seen the new American Idol opening, featuring Jennifer Hudson and Adam Lambert (they are STILL trying to make him happen-happen) along with the winners. They even have a separate White Guy With Guitar section featuring David Cook, Kris Allen, and Lee DeWyze (they are NEVER gonna try and make him happen). Guess what? The opening is still lame and it has not changed my life. Nor has it changed yours.

If you even think that intro paragraph gives you carte blanche to discuss any of those people (Granted…I could handle some Jennifer Hudson talk. How can anyone not adore that girl?), you’re clearly an idiot. THIS IS SEASON 10. Forget the past, dammit. Of course, since we are in Milwaukee this evening, I do believe it is fair to discuss one formal Idol contestant if you so desire. Just look at that goon.

Danny Gokey returns to American Idol and Milwaukee

No matter where Danny Gokey puts his hands, they always seem to be shaping a damned heart.

$25 says Jennifer Lopez had never heard of Milwaukee before this evening. She thinks Lake Michigan looks like the ocean. Hey…it is a big lake, so I assume she was attesting to this fact after Randy called it an ocean. Or maybe she was trying to correct him. Oh who cares. Steven Tyler is howling his crazy babble and I just showed up for the crazy babble howls.

(Dear American Idol. We are not idiots. Stop trying to make us believe Jackson, Lopez and Tyler saw thousands of wannabes audition. And yes. I will say this during EVERY SINGLE ARDUOUS AUDITION SHOW.)

Scotty McCreery
Scotty gets coverage of him doing shit in his hometown of Garner, North Carolina. He is 16. His name is Scotty. He also wears a big fat cross and sings country music. He’s like a pickup truck Clay Aiken. This kid is a one-trick pony. Steven Tyler asks him to sing something that stands the test of time. We then learn Randy Jackson once produced something for Travis Tritt. I still think Scotty McCreery is a one-trick pony, but if Michael Bay goes back to directing Chevy commercials, he should totally sing for that campaign. Scotty McCreery just sounds like a Chevy truck commercial.

Well hellfire, save matches, f**k a duck and see what hatches.

Oh Steven Tyler. I so cannot wait for when this show goes live.

Aspiring radio dj Big Joe Repka on American Idol

Joe Repka
You already know this guy is going to be humiliated given the fact he looks like Peter Griffin and is an aspiring radio DJ in Toledo who goes by the name Big Joe. I suspect he might be okay with humiliation, as he is likely doing this for a radio station stunt. I also cannot believe this guy is…this guy is…19?

The judges tell them to keep his day job. Big Joe keeps singing. But hey, Big Joe, you will probably get a little bit of fame in Toledo after this, no? And maybe even a big fat radio job! Exposure is everything.

Emma Henry
Golly gee. Another 15-year-old. A 15-year-old with a terrible dye job, which is how younguns express themselves. Bad dye jobs. She’s wanted to be on the show since seeing Kelly Clarkson win during Season 1. Emma sings True Colors and her voice is mildly interesting, yet not mature enough. There are shades of say, Adele, but she does not really seem to have much control over it yet. But she’s too young. Her voice is just not there. I am also shocked I agree with Jennifer Lopez on this one, but she just ain’t ready. J. Lo says no. Steven says yes (she’s a young girl wearing a skirt). IT IS ALL UP TO RANDY. And Randy is totally RIGHT. Give this girl a couple of years. Hey, the show might not be on by then but for chrissake, you’re only 15 little Emma Skunkhair. But this gives Stevie Tyler another chance to let out one of his high-pitched whoops and Emma’s tears get her a ticket to Hollywood.

Another commercial. Promising more tears, more girls with flowers in their hair, and a Civil War reenactment after the break.

THE PART WHERE THEY SHOW SEVERAL PEOPLE WHO SUCK DONKEY BALLS

Kody Zalewski
So you tell people you have a bluesy voice. Like Frank Sinatra. And then you come out swinging (literally) to Lady Gaga’s Bad Romance?

Juanita Borges is Juanita GORGEOUS on American Idol

Juanita Borges
Juanita Borges is JUANITA GORGEOUS! This luscious lady has DListed Hot Slut of the Day written all over her face. From the her black Wet ‘N’ Wild lips to the crushed black velvet mid-drift baring boudoir ensemble, finishing off with lucite stilettos as seen in your favorite backwoods strip club, Juanita is perfection in plumpness. So…is she pregnant?

Kamil Anthony
Also singing Bad Romance. Why do I have a feeling there’s gonna be a Bad Romance montage at some point?

Kanisha Miller
Kanisha screams Alicia (Keys) and looks like she’s in the midst of trying to take a crap after eating nothing but cheese for 2 days straight. Yawn.

(Kody totally did this on a dare. Which is why he asked for a hug and a sip of Randy’s Coke Zero.)

Truth be told, I had no idea Milwaukee was home to the world’s biggest music festival. Have I ever even heard of this Summerfest?

Naima Adedapo auditions for American Idol in Milwaukee

Naima Adedapo
Even though she has a flower in her hair, Naima Adedapo also has dreads and wears the colors of Africa. She also has two daughters and cries nicely. Her career is termed Grounds Cleanup on the chryon. She is also quite striking. (We already know she’s made it to the Top 40, btw.) She might just even have a fun personality. She is also the first contestant I’ve seen this season who actually kind of EXCITES me.

(Cut to me. Still waiting for the Civil War reenactment.)

Jovan Raymond
Who cares how she does? Jovan gets MAD PROPS for singing Jenny From The Block! Do you guys remember that video? You know who wishes they could forget it? Well, besides Ben Affleck. Jennifer Lopez. It just brings back too many memories and bitch is staring daggers.

Chris Kammer
Idiot with a Will Ferrerll complex shows up in some silver pajamas with a giant toothbrush. A complete gimmick. (He’s also 54? And a dentist?) A complete gimmick lacking any bit of actual humor. Next, please.

Jerome Bell
Jerome is a Bar Mitzvah singer, good looking, and a snappy dresser. So is he Jewish? I don’t exactly know what American Idol would do with a Jew of Color. It might confuse. Heads might explode. Jerome belts out a satisfactory Let’s Get It On full of bombast. He’s nothing you haven’t seen before and nothing you won’t ever see again. But give him the ticket. Shalom.

Obligatory Justin Bieber bit in the hopes tweens are watching. Some 5-year-old sings. This gives Ryan Seacrest a chance to talk about all those talented 15-year-olds. He even admits they want the next Bieber. HA. HA. Not gonna happen. I’m getting kind of bored…

Thia Megia
Here she is! This is the girl everyone just loves, singing Adele! Thia Megia was heavily promoted in the pre-season advertisements. Thia Megia was on America’s Got Talent. I don’t care what This Lego My Eggo teenager sounds like. Homegirl is a plant. And why can’t high school kids like, just be high school kids? And have aspirations of going to college while doing show choir or joining a band or something. Blame the parents. Thia Megia really needs a TIGER MOTHER. (BTW, I like Tiger Mom. Rock on, Tiger Mom.)

American Idol is pretty much taking any teenager who comes a’knocking just because those menopausal frumpy ladies foaming at the mouth and plucking their chin hairs while watching and voting every week have done nothing but sink their once-powerful brand.

CIVIL WAR REENACTMENT TIME! FINALLY!

Civil War Reenactor Nathaniel Jones on American IdolNathaniel Jones
Is your Dad a hippie? (Huh?)

No. He’s not a hippie. Hippies believe in sex.

Finally. An original gimmick. I’m not sure if this kid is batshit crazy or just a guy who came up with a fairly decent gimmick to get some screen time. Perhaps I should thank that fucker Jared Loughner for making me raise one eyebrow out of concern whenever I see a 22-year-old dude spouting some cray-cray. And I’ve never heard of any Civil War reenactor engaging in a killing spree at a supermarket, so I’m just gonna assume Nathaniel Jones is the good kind of crazy we need a bit more of during these tedious American Idol audition shows.

Plus, the dude gets props for singing The Lion Sleeps Tonight and…kinda sorta somewhat on key. It is by no means good. By no means. But it captured the spirit…of something. THANK YOU STEVEN TYLER. You spoke the truth. Maybe not for American Idol, but somewhere, somewhere perhaps. Somewhere the lions sleep at night in Gettysburg or something.

Mason Wilkinson on American Idol

Mason Wilkinson
I have no fraking clue but this is one of the most FANTASTIC AUDITIONS EVER. Finally a few actual moments of exquisitely dreadful entertainment. Alas. I think he was humiliated so now I’m kind of sad. I’m sensitive.

White House Intern Molly DeWolf Swensen on American Idol

Molly DeWolf Swensen
Molly just graduated from Harvard and is a current White House intern. She loves Obama. Molly has blond hair and her name is Molly but I desperately want to love her, and not just because Randy accidentally punched her in the mouth while running around giving high fives earlier that day. Look at this girl. Look at how she can be used in the fight against lunatic Republicans with her blond hair and slender, Ann Coulter frame. How is Fox even allowing such things? I want to love Molly, but for chrissake, Harvard? THE WHITE HOUSE? Let’s just break it down. FUCK AMERICAN IDOL. Why are you here? OMG Molly is an alto. Molly I love you. I love you so much I just don’t want you to be here.

It is now Day 2! How can this be? I’ve been watching this shit show for the last 5 hours. It must get better. I mean, Steven Tyler needs to just do a reality show where he shares a house with Keith Richards. Who wouldn’t watch it? Tyler is even campaigning for a role as Keith Richards’ brother / Johnny Depp’s uncle in Pirates of the Carribbean 16: Deep Seas Rehab.

Steven Tyler looks like a pirate

(If Milwaukee only has Danny Gokey and Summerfest to offer musically, well then. Why are you playing Violent Femmes’ classic ode to masturbation?)

Haley Reinhart
This is the closest I’ve seen to Steven Tyler creep on a young girl all night. Boo. Yeah, its sometimes inappropriate and creepy, but its not like Bret Michaels hasn’t done worse and gotten several seasons of VH1 for it. And what the hell else are aging rock stars supposed to do?

Haley’s voice is fine, I guess. But she’s boring. She has not attended Harvard or interned at the White House. I don’t even think she’s snorted meth inside a port-a-potty. Haley also feels the music in an annoyingly cloying way. She has the personality of a house plant. And Jennifer Lopez is wearing quite possibly the lamest, cheesiest shirt ever made that costs thousands of coin. A fraking treble clef on a silk t-shirt boasting a rhinestone crewneck? Even Randy Jackson thinks you look stupid.

Tiwan Strong
Its pronounced Taiwan. Yeah. Like the country. I wonder where this name came from. I wonder how many people, upon meeting Tiwan Strong, say Hey Tiwan on me! The 29-year-old child care person sings an oldie and charms the judges. He’s good enough for Hollywood. He kind of looks like a pocket-sized Shaq, too! Me? I really want to go the beauty shop with every single woman in his family because this looks like hella fun. And that is no-lye. (NO! The little one was so excited, she got a charley horse!)

Tiwan Strong's sister got a charlie horse on American Idol

Steve Beghun
A CPA. An auditor. He doesn’t have many friends. Quick. Someone look for his OKCupid.com profile! The dude is also wearing flip flops and I can’t stop staring at them. Men in flip flops just don’t work. As expected, Steve’s not too terrible a singer. His voice is a bit high and I’m not sure how much control he has over it, but he’s not bad–even if he makes J. Lo tell some forgettable story about her kid. (She did that so we will think she’s all sorts of caring mother or something.) Steve is going to Hollywood. In his flip flops, I imagine. Hey, at least he has a good day job to fall back on.

Vernika Patterson
Vernika is singing Minnie Ripperton’s Lovin’ You. Trivia: Who is Minnie Ripperton’s daughter? Answer: Maya Rudolph. LA-LA-LA-LA-LA–LA-LA-LA-LA-LA–LA-LA-LA-LA. Vernika is not happening, but at least you learned something. Ooooh. We are not done. Vernika is gonna shank a bitch. I can sing better than half of these people in the competition. She thinks its because she’s not skinny. Randy then points to a hidden photo of Ruben Studdard or something.

THAT’S A MAN! I’m talking about females.

Randy then says how the first winner wasn’t…then cuts himself off. Oh, Randy Jackson. You had your stomach stapled and you got your moobs back. Don’t you dare even call Kelly Clarkson fat.

REQUISITE ANGRY PEOPLE MONTAGE

Albert Rogers III
(Dear Saturday Night Live, having Fred Armisen imitate our African-American Commander In Chief is pretty lame. I think you guys need this dude.) Albert Rogers III, btw, was not as terrible as the judges purported him to be.

Scott Dangerfield
I had no idea this surname existed outside of Rodney. Student teacher Scott Dangerfield (How is he not one of the floppy-haired 15-year-old boys?) shows up with lipstick. Claims he was kissing someone. It gives Steven Tyler a chance to sing Piece of My Heart. I’m really glad J. Lo doesn’t ever interject with singing, but I don’t believe she would ever be caught without Autotune. Back to Scott Dangerfield…he’s not bad. But he sort of sounded like I assumed he would sound when he showed up. And I do not believe he is 22-years-old. Do 22-year-olds look this young these days? But remember that 19-year-old Big Joe? He looked at least 30. And what am I talking about? I look 27! I’m really grasping at things to talk about here, can you tell?

This is a real person. This is a real shirt. This is a real person wearing a real shirt.

Packers superfan Megan Frazier auditions for American Idol

Megan Frazier
Why is this girl wearing this hideous SkyMall button-down and not a Packers jersey. Her family isn’t even wearing Packers attire. NOT TRUE FANS. I don’t even care how much they shout LAMBEAU FIELD or GO PACK GO with their quaint Wisconsin accents. To continue on with the theme of WTF, Megan reaches a true crescendo when her mouth shapes into a perfect O and out comes Justin Bieber’s Baby. (Oh-oh-oh-oh-oh yes. It popped right out of her operatic mouth.)

Alyson Jados
Ally wants to bring more rock & roll to American Idol. Ally is cute. If Ally sings well, I will love Ally. Ally loves Steven Tyler. Instead of being weird like those ones they showed us last week, this time, its all sorts of adorbs.

You look like you could be…one of my friends.

Loves it. All sorts of adorbs! Ally sings The Beatles’ Come Together. (Quick! Someone find me a Kris Allen tard who says HOW DARE SHE? There must be one, right? Go scan your Twitter.) I love Ally…even if, as Steven Tyler says, she’s a bit pitchy. I think he just wanted to call someone pitchy. She then belts out Dream On. (Now find me a Danny Gokey tard who says HOW DARE SHE?) Now Steven Tyler must decide her fate. Oh Stevie, don’t ruin her dream. Thank you, Stevie Tyler. Remember, she looks like she could be…one of your friends.

UNNECESSARY RECAP OF THOSE WE SAW 6 HOURS AGO BEFORE MANIPULATIVE SOB STORY

Chris Medina auditions for American Idol 10 in Milwaukee

Chris Medina
Saving the ULTIMATE FRAU BAIT, 26-year-old Chris Medina looks like the love child of Jack Black and Season 5 contestant, Walking VD Constantine Maroulis. He wears his fiancee’s photo somewhere. He proposed to her in a Starbucks. I guess he works there. Don’t get me started on my feelings towards Starbucks, let alone proposing in a fraking Starbucks. Sometime after, there was a bad car accident and his fiancee was severely injured. They thought she was brain dead. She woke up. But she’s pretty much in a vegitative state. Her mother and him are her caretakers. They have no problem showing her in this condition on TV. Tell me, dear reader — WHAT DO YOU THINK? Is it necessary? Do you feel as if you’ve been manipulated? Do you, like me, wonder about these young men from Milwaukee (cough Danny Gokey cough) who like to sing and have dead or almost-dead wives/almost-wives? Is it something in the water?

Chris Medina sings The Script’s Breakeven and sets the hearts of 1000 bored frauen aflutter. (I can think of one in particular. You know who I’m talking about…First there was Cook…then Gokey…then your cousin Phil DeWheezy…now Chris Medina. She likes those of a particular age with a particular kind of sob story.) Holy shit. They brought the fiancee. (Why do they keep calling her girlfriend? Are you demoted to the role of girlfriend if in any sort of vegetative state?) I can’t even take a photo of this shit. The poor girl is involuntarily shaking in her wheelchair and has no idea what is going on. There’s just something about it…what’s that word? Its not the willies. But its like the willies. But not quite the willies. It’s just all so wrong. Even worse than proposing marriage at a Starbucks in between the branded thermal mugs and Sheryl Crow CDs.

Wow. How many hours was that? Tomorrow night, Idol goes somewhere else. Can’t recall, but its only an hour. Until then, my friends:

NEVER FORGET

Bennifer in "Jersey Girl"

  • ddevon14

    Who ever wrote this article was just a whiney little bitch who was trying to be funny but really just came off as a loser. Go gets some taste before you write another article you whiney little BITCH

  • Dickory Dock

    I refuse to be ashamed by how much I love hating Gokey. *hand gestures* That’s right Gokey, them ain’t hearts.

    This Pimp My Crip (tm caspar) character is just … christ, where to even start with this guy. I would call him a filthy grave robber but his fiance is still alive. He’s one of those third-rate 19th century traveling circus barkers, pitching his tent on the outskirts of the grounds and calling folks over to whore out his tragic fiance for a few coin and some fleeting attention.

    Peek behind the curtain to see the girl in the wheelchair! Watch as I lovingly strap her in! Observe what a good guy I am! I can (sort of) sing, too! Step right up! It costs only 50 cents and your soul!

    He’s willing to shill for the cameras and turn her tragic story into 3 minute anecdote that people he doesn’t even, and never will, know can talk about it over coffee at the office tomorrow. I bet the frauen at mj’s are wetting himself over this courageous young man’s story. Pardon me while I go hork.

    Feh. I’m going back to watching Peter Stormare drink beer, mime masturbate, and play the ukulele.

    • Dickory Dock

      Well. I was so disturbed I lost all power over grammar, syntax and spelling. I are ashamed.

  • ross

    Somebody told me Matt Giraud was standing there with Gokey and they didn’t include him in the shot.

    • Dickory Dock

      QUATTO!

  • caspar

    I’m calling him ‘Pimp my Crip’ Medina.

    I do think in fairness that it would probably have been hard to conceal his story from the producers, since his occupation is basically ‘home health care provider’. And once they found out about girlfriend, they would put pressure on him to bring her in for the later auditions, and he might have thought it gave him a foot in the door (and, alas, he’s correct). BUT: He could have said No.

    And sorry, TI, I don’t like J Hud; she always looks way too self satisfied and she has an…opaque? quality that puts up my hackles (Oskar knows what I mean!) Great, great voice, though.

    • http://topidolblog.com TopIdol

      Imagine what Idol would have done had J Hud’s tragic backstory happened before her time on the show? Sickening.

      Also. PIMP MY CRIP is one of the funniest things I’ve ever heard. We are using this. You rule. Gold Star. Wear special hat. LOVES IT.

    • http://drlulzington.wordpress.com Doctor Lulzington

      “I don’t even think she’s snorted meth inside a port-a-potty. “

      Give it time. She’s only 18.

      “caspar permalink
      January 27, 2011

      I’m calling him ‘Pimp my Crip’ Medina. “
      Best nickname ever.

    • ross

      Great, great voice, though.

      Maybe but I can’t stand that kind of singing.

      • DeeDee

        I thought it was just me. I watched Dreamgirls and had to fast forward through her big song because I found it so annoying.

        • vtu

          Definitely not just you. I have to mute the TV whenever her weight watchers commercial comes on so she won’t ruin Feelin Good for me.

          • ross

            Not to put too fine a point on it, but singers like her are why I could never stand AI in those days.

        • http://topidolblog.com TopIdol

          I really do loathe that song.

  • auntieaimee

    I’m not sure how I feel about the Chris Medina thing. My first impression was that I found it really distasteful that they had her sitting there in the holding room for God knows how long and you just know that one of the producers made her hold onto the sign for effect. For her sake, I really hope his was one of the first auditions that day because I’m sure she doesn’t make it outside of her house very often and the thought of her sitting in a waiting room all day made me sad. And I was kind of pissed when he started singing and he pretty much sucked. I was like, what is the point of all this? He knows he’s not that great. It really bothered me. After sleeping on it though, I thought, you know, this girl is going to need 24 hour care for the rest of her life. I’m not talking about therapy, but basic care (bathing, toileting, feeding). That costs money. If seeing her inspires someone to throw some money her way to help pay for her care, so what. Good for them. Let’s be honest, her mother is her primary caregiver. If people want to donate so that the mother can have respite, to be able go out for a cup of coffee every once and a while, then that’s a good thing. Even though the girl is severely disabled, I’m sure she would be more comfortable being cared for at home than to be stuck in a nursing home.:(

    Now that I’m thoroughly bummed out again, I will say that I absolutely loved Naima. Loved her voice, loved her style, loved HER. There was something so compelling about her. She’s not a pageant bot, though, so I fear that she won’t get very far. Voters seem to love their beauty queen pageant bots.

    Jerome was adorable but LOUD. Whoa. Bring it down a notch, dude.

    Kind of liked Hahvahd girl Molly, too, but when she first started singing with that low voice I thought she was a tranny who forgot her hormones. Tall, rangy girl with big nose and a deeeep voice made me look closer for an Adam’s apple. She was better as she went along. She’ll go nowhere though.

    Liked Thia’s voice. Too many affectations, but I love alto girls. She’s young though, hopefully she’ll settle into her own style.

    I can’t stop singing “The Man Who Can’t Be Moved” today. Good audition for Bigoun. Bighun? He also will go nowhere.

  • mylifeback

    How *DARE* that bitch sing Come Together!!!#(@(&*#@*&!!! Kris Allen’s version was the best version of all time. OF. ALL. TIME. !!!ELEVENTY111!!

    OK, so I admit to watching all three of the audition episodes this year, mainly to see the judges panel (which I love). I’ll bet the person in charge of the bleep button for the live episodes is sweating bullets right about now. But back to the episode.

    Ugh, seriously Idol? That dog & pony show at the end was a new low. Honestly, it was just sickening, manipulative, and in such poor taste. I really, really, hate these backstories.

  • cb

    Watched Idol last night and decided it was time to check back in with TI. Can’t believe the BSC are still at it. Some of us have jobs. Where do they get the time?
    Melinda, your review would fit in perfect with the snarky texting conversation I had with my sister while watching.
    Too many Gokey flashbacks :P At least Steven finished Dream On. I swore I was going to throw the remote at the tv if the last guy’s wife was dead. Idol producers must have peed their pants when they found this family. Looks like a legit triumphing over near fatal injury story with a Prince Charming that stuck around for the worse, sickness, and bad times part of the vows he had yet to say. I really don’t want to see how they top the sob story next season 8) Now taking applications from war orphans with terminal cancer and missing limbs and whose puppy was just run over.

    • http://topidolblog.com TopIdol

      This sounds so horribly cynical of me but…if the mother was giving him a free place to live…

      I’m horrible. I know it. But the entire segment devoted to Chris Medina just left me with a bad taste in my mouth. That poor girl. Why did she need to be on TV? How much do you want to bet they wheel her into the audience every week once the show goes live? Exploiting this poor girl is terrible.

      • B York

        “How much do you want to bet they wheel her into the audience every week once the show goes live?”

        I think I was so aghast that she was at the audition and wheeled in that it never crossed my mind that they might take her to Hollywood.

        • http://topidolblog.com TopIdol

          He’s in the TOP 40.

          Also, did you guys see what the Gokester posted to Twitter this morning?

          People hated me 4 sharing my story on idol & now Im already seeing their starting 2 bash Chris Medina for his. His story will help many!!

          • B York

            Sheesh, now Medina will be encouraged to start a scam Juliette’s Brain Foundation.

          • http://topidolblog.com TopIdol

            I want him to make brain shapes with his hands.

          • et

            I want him to make brain shapes with his hands.

            That just gave me the guiltiest case of the giggles ever. Hee.

  • kissy marks

    I completely agree with you. That last contestant’s “story” crossed every ethical boundary in the book. As if that poor woman would have *wanted* to be trotted out and put on display just for the sake of television ratings. Everyone involved should be ashamed.

    In happier news, it now appears that anyone with a crippled or deformed or impaired family member is, de facto, a good singer. All that grief must give them special vocal powers.

    • http://topidolblog.com TopIdol

      Yet they still do not seem to allow midgets :(

      • et

        I would most definitely vote for a midget. Why don’t they have midgets?

        (Last summer I was at the park and a girl on a pink bike with ribbons on the handlebars rode by and I thought she was a kid but she was a midget. Um, little person? And then right behind her came a lady pushing a Dachshund in a pink doll stroller. Like grown lady. And I wasn’t even tripping.)

  • suew

    Hilarious recap, TI. The Packers girl was all sorts of disturbing. I have to give credit to David Cook for NEVER milking his sob story (or letting Idol do so) for his entire time on the show, even while he was experiencing tough times with his brother. I also noticed the picture of Adam at the beginning, and was wondering where the pictures of the other “runner-ups” were – i.e. David Archuleta and Crystal Bowersox.

  • unohav_1

    The Medina dude…Cantiello linked a youtube video after the show…He has a band and named it THE ABLE BODY…

    Sorry I’m just so…flummoxed. Eugh.

    • http://topidolblog.com TopIdol

      The song he wrote for his fiancee after the accident also has some WTF DOES THIS MEAN part about “the public eye.” Perhaps there was a controversy surrounding her accident? Or he fancied himself famous? I may need to listen to the song again b/c in the context, it does not seem to make sense.

  • Udderly Shiny

    Medina is a repulsive creature.

  • Singingdog101

    One of those 15 year olds who made it to Hollywood from Milwaukee was not featured on the show tonite. She is much, much better than ANY 15 year old they have shown so far. They are pushing Thia Megia, so they couldn’t show any 15 year old who was better than Thia. Her name is Hanani Taylor. She is phenomenal. She was a “Kid Star of Tomorrow” on “Showtime at the Apollo” at age 9. America would have been in for a real treat but they didn’t show her singing. She auditioned with “I Am Changing.” I saw her audition in the stadium at Milwaukee. No one could believe her big, strong Jennifer Hudson singing voice. Watch her on YouTube at:
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zXMEXwk8KVU

  • barado

    Thanks for watching this for me, TI. So, they showed a contestant with a Gokeyesque backstory auditioning in Milwaukee with the Gokester himself appearing earlier in the episode. I’m trying to process all this. Are TPTB deliberately insulting the intelligence of their audience? I know, they’re trying to drive away any voters that won’t fall for their machinations. But, shouldn’t they be trying to attract viewers and voters?