... ...

SYTYCD Top 11: And the first one falls — But wait! There’s Bieber!

2010 June 17

The first So You Think You Can Dance results show of Season 7! Who will be going home? Alexie? Adechike? Melinda? Ashley? Is Melinda the only contestant whose name does not begin with A?

LESS THAN 24 HOURS UNTIL WE CAN ALL BUY CAT DEELEY’S MODERN VINTAGE JEWELRY ON QVC!!!ELEVENTY!!!

The dancers open the show with a group routine set to Kelis’ Acapella. Everyone is wearing the used panties of a Caesar Palace cocktail waitress circa 1992. The girls’ outfits are terrible. These ladies have gorgeous bodies and most of them are bizarrely unflattering. The Goddess Cat Deeley, if she had more time, SHE could design their outfits. Speaking of The Goddess, tonight’s retro chiffon plaid frock displays a piece from her soon-to-be-unveiled jewelry collection on the shoulder, and while the dress is undoubtedly cute in a most Betty Draper way, it does come off a tad bit autumnal, no?

My ADHD has now kicked in and I’ve paused the show to hit the Dizzy Feet Foundation website to learn this Dance Day routine from Nappy Tabs. I’m not the only one with that idea! The damn site crashed. This dance seems kind of difficult, but I’ve only been trying it while seated, so…

Back to the show. Usher is going to be performing, so I’ll fast-forward through that nonsense. I thought I recalled The Goddess Cat Deeley mumbling something under her breath about the Moppet of Beelzebub/Imp of Hades Justin Bieber being there? Before then, Cat is going to start picking off the contestants one by one. It’s amusing how Alex Wong looks frightful when she starts with him. But in regards to Alex being safe? Just like Cat said, of course you are. As if there was any doubt.

Robert will also not be eliminated, because everyone male or female watching this show, wants to hit that shit. Shankman called him one of the best contemporary dancers in the history of the show. Damn straight. And I wonder if he is. Perhaps he is bi. Then everyone will be happy.

I’m not quite sure what the allure of Lauren is, as she’s blond and sort of forgettable. I mean, she’s no Mollee Gray or anything terrible like that, she’s just kind of…there? In last night’s routine to that goddamned Ferris Bueller / The Secret of My Success / Twix commercial song, Lauren was completely outshone by ADE (Love Ade!) and appeared to neither connect with the choreography or Ade. Ohio farm boy Kent is safe, of course, because you’re just soulless if you don’t adore Kent. The Goddess totally fakes them out! Lauren is safe, too. Funny, whenever Cat fakes a contestant out like that, it never appears as if she is toying with them in a cruel or unkind way. And then everyone gets together and HUGS! Betty Draper would NEVER show Sally and Bobby such affection. Only overworked housekeeper Carla would embrace those Little Drapers as Cat Deeley does her “kids.”

I love you, Cat Deeley. Love. You.

Melinda reminds me of someone annoying when she dances and I cannot place it. She really is a pretty girl, though, but she doesn’t come off as very likable in her pre-performance packages, so there certainly is truth in Nigel’s assessment that she does not show enough warmth. And really, is she a dancer or a dancer who just wants to be an actress? It’s no surprise she is in tonight’s bottom 3.

Nigel’s comparison of Billy Bell to Jaden Smith has been repeated 55 times. It lends credence to my believe SYTYCD could be an arm of Scientology! Extended preview of Knight & Day? Katie Homes a partner in Dizzy Feet? Mentioning Jaden fraking Smith — aka the kid who might just beat out Justin Bieber in the category of pre-pubescent douchebag and is likely a Scientologist? Anyway, Billy Bell, of course, is safe.

Ashley is safe, likely because she looks like a female version of Mark Kanemura (who is adorable, if you have yet to notice). Alexie is in the Bottom 3, which is kind of sad, not because she’s just so damn cute (at least that’s what they keep telling us), but because it would really suck for her to finally make it after trying out 3 times to be booted during week 1. I mean, that’s just COLD.

Jose Ruiz is safe, which is cool, b/c he seems like a nice guy. I’m worried about my boy Adechike, though. Side note, don’t you love watching Kathryn McCormick dance? In fact, I REALLY hope Adechike is safe because I’ve now caught a glimpse of what Cristina is wearing.

I get it. You’re a salsa dancer. And you’re a fiery Latina. But ugly is ugly, and that looks like a dust mop found in the home of a fierce Brazilian drag queen. That dress is a crime against fabric. Her name was Carmen — not Kmart — Miranda. Jesus christ, woman. You should be forced to dance for not only your life, but the lives of all your unborn children for wearing that number. (Side note — if Mark Kanemura and Ashley dance together something sexy, I might get all creeped out in a Flowers in the Attic kind of way.)

YAY! Adechike is safe. The men are much stronger than the girls this season, and I’m not even saying this in a bullshit American Idol kind of way. I also do not believe SYTYCD power texting is yet dominated by menopausal frauen.

Frak me. Justin Bieber WORLD PREMIERE. There is a very important Celtics game on, dammit. I’m sure the Twyla Twarp people dancing to Frank Sinatra are even more wonderful than they appear for an instant and on fast forward, but I just don’t have time.

Melinda taps for her life. She is kind of hunched over most of the time, but I think that’s a tap dancing thing. Alexie does the typical dance-for-one’s-life EVERY contemporary female dancer does on the show and I am unimpressed. At least the tap dancing is like, you know, a somewhat rare thing on this show.

YES! I figured it out. Melinda looks just like Silver on the new-fangled 90210, which I inexplicably watch although I spent high school and college laughing at my friends who watched the original. Initially, I found Silver to be very pretty, gorgeous almost. But then she went crazy and cut her hair into a bob which does not work for her, and didn’t quite conceal the fact she’s like, oh Ian Ziering’s age when he was on the original. Melinda has crazy Silver teeth or something, not sure. But she’s a Melinda! We must like her!

Cristina does her salsa thing. Her facial expressions are mildly less disconcerting than in her previous performances, yet, the dress just…let’s just get on with the show. There’s Usher. Convinced Justin Bieber is really a Magic Grow Capsule that Usher carries around in his pocket as a party trick. Not sure if he’s there tonight, but video from when Usher took him over to P. Diddy’s Memorial Day party (or maybe it was Knotts Berry Farm) is:

I want to know why I cannot look away. It’s like when I was 19 and first saw the Hanson Mmm-Bop video. I happened to have just smoked a bunch of weed. This is the same thing, except I have not smoked any pot. Wait. Is this that song from The Karate Kid? There are Asian-ish fans. Oh crap. It is. There is Asian lettering. Is Justin Bieber a Scientologist now? He’s hanging out with Jaden Smith, isn’t he? I’m not going to think about it. I can’t. Just tell me why some kid who hasn’t even hit puberty is singing about needing somebody to love? He’s [allegedly] SIXTEEN YEARS OLD. He needs to be in school thinking about his PSAT.

Whew! It’s almost over. Sadly, Alexie is going home because she wasn’t very good tonight. And she dances kind of juvenile, however, she’s the oldest. All of her fellow contestants are in tears, which makes me sad. Plus, I was rooting for the girl who wanted it so much, who tried out so many times. The judges all tell her not to worry, however, because she is employable. And hey, this is the only reality show where the contestants actually go on to work in their chosen field, so it could be much, much worse for our little Alexie.

And to you, Mary Murphy, I raise my imaginary Captain & Diet for you. I cannot drink a real one unless you’re drinking with me. (Until I go out this weekend. Obviously.) Go Celtics!

Spread the word. Do it.
[Facebook] [Google] [Reddit] [StumbleUpon] [Twitter] [Yahoo!] [Email]
  • TankieGirlie

    I need my recaps! Anyone know of a good SYTYCD ‘Capper?

    • http://topidolblog.com TopIdol

      I know! I will get around to that tonight. Promise! I am not going to stop recapping SYTYCD.

  • TankieGirlie

    Um…Cat is mine!! Funny you picked Adechike, I think he’s the weakest of the bunch albeit adorable. I liked Lauren from Vegas, she puts it all in, but Mandy Moore needs to be taken out and shot. Oooh goody another cheesy 80′s song and a routine that consisted of jumping on and off a chair! God I hate her!!

    I liked last week (2) I loved many of the routines. Jose, I just wanna SMUSH!! That Bollywood was adorkable!!

    Billy, crumping…Bwahahahaha

    I love this show..Idol what?

  • caspar

    I think Justa Beaver’s voice has a nice quality to it. Song was horrifying, of course. And I do hope he’s saving his $$$- JMO, but he will not age well.

    And I could swear Usher did that exact same routine to OMG on Idol- stairs, etc. I do give him credit for singing live, because even someone as in shape as he clearly is rarely has enough wind to do fast dancing and sing well.

  • MissMyEm

    I thought all of them were good on Wednesday, but some were just better than others. What can I say…I think Billy Bell is great but so far my two favorites are Jose and Kent. TI, you are right…how can you not love Kent? I actually like Cristina because I like to see variety in the type of dancers and she’s the only Salsa dancer there, so I hope she stays. Unfortunately, with the exception of the Family Schwimmer (yes, I love them), ballroom and salsa dancers don’t seem to make it til the end, which is a bummer because I absolutely love Pascha and am glad he’s back.

    The problem with Alexie, as cute as she is, was she was dancing with the fabulous Twitch and I would not be surprised to hear that people focused on him more and forgot about her. It’s hard not to focus on Twitch.

    Tappers don’t seem to go far either. Last season there were several tappers that I liked but poof…they were all gone at the beginning. I think the problem with tap is that, for the most part, most of the celebrated tap dancers have been males and it’s possible to the voters, female tappers may come across as not flowing as gracefully as perhaps the modern dancers. Maybe. I don’t really know, but while I was watching Melinda dance, that’s what I noted. There doesn’t seem to be a gracefulness to her dancing. Her Jive was too foot heavy and that, I think was her downfall.

    I love Cat, but I thought that Lee DeWyze and his bagpiper would be descending the stairs any moment. I am just not a plaid kind of girl.

    I agree that when Cat toys with someone…basically she teases so it doesn’t come across as harsh as say…mmmm…I don’t know…Ryan Seacrest maybe.

    I also would rather Mary Murphy be on the panel, but her screeching does get old. I’m not overly fond of Mia Michaels as a choreographer or a judge and I’m glad they have Sonya and Travis to pick up where she leaves off.

    Also…Nigel Lythgoe to me is a classic example of passive aggressive and I just don’t like him, but since he’s the Exec. Producer, I suppose we are stuck with him. Unless of course he makes a big faux pas like he did on Idol and they replace him with Howie Mandel. Or David Hasselhoff.

    • MissMyEm

      Oh and I was watching Top Chef before this so I was able to fast forward past Usher and Usher/Bieber. I actually like Usher’s song, but he sounds different live than he does on his recording. I’m also tired of twenty dancers in the background and glitz and lights. What ever happened to just come to the mic and sing?

  • CayKat

    Didn’t catch the results show so thank you for this great recap! VERY happy that I missed the Moppet, Usher and all things Scientology.

    Very happy that Baby Jesus and Robert aka “Everybody wants a piece” made it through. Also like Alex and Adechike.

    Kathryn is untouchable in my eyes. The girl is just amazing. I really wanted her to win last year and I am sooo happy she’s back with the all stars this year. The girls that made it to the top 11 this year are lukewarm for me.

  • wino

    does anyone know why mary isnt on the judges panel this season? there is something missing without the hot tamale train :(

    LOVE kathryn. she’s just so damn flawless in her moves, i become lost in her dancing. an alex and kat pairing could be mesmerizing. she and jakob were my faves last season….and if it wasnt for russ’ popularity and that stupid top six finale format, i think she could’ve won.

    anyhoo, this season my eyes are on the boys. the only girl who could be a spoiler is ashley, she has potential.

    btw, this was worth the wait Melinda! thanx

    • Pandora

      Mary is doing choreography this season instead of judging. And yes, Kathyrn is un-fraking-believable. Cannot wait to see her dance with Alex. Perhaps to I Need to Know?

    • Mithra

      Maybe her screaming finally got old to someone in charge?

      Cristina’s dress was hideous, but I liked her routine and was suprised she was in the bottom three. The women really are not that interesting, yet. Perhaps they just had bad luck of the draw. Are they going out on tour this year? Didn’t they skip a tour because it was a fall season last year?

      That video with Beiber was just plain disturbing at first. He’s totally out of place with adults, and he’s not trying to play the part of a ten year old kid, which he should. It’s like Gaspy videos, except Beiber thinks he’s sexay… I couldn’t stop laughing through the second half.

  • Mary

    Melinda can you please please may an epilogue for the Boston Celtics???

    • Mary

      and make fun of ron artest thanking his shrink?

      • wino

        ha, Ron is da man. he thanked his hood, his wife and then his shrink. man has his priorities straight. i grew up in inglewood five minutes away from the Forum, so despite having kobe (ugh) on our team, im still a lakers girl at heart and glad they won :)

      • jukejoint

        Which team is Kevin Garnett on? I root against any team with him on it.

        • Mary

          Damn you, jukejoint :) He’s on the Celtics.

          • jukejoint

            I saw him play in high school. Carpetbagger, diva, ringer… Not somebody I would root for. I also saw Quentin Richardson play in high school. He was a class act and had the talent to back up all the talk. He also won the state championships for his high school. Garnett? Not so much.

    • Mary

      I’m a die hard Celtics fan, so disappointed they lost :(
      Even though I hate the Lakers, Ron Artest is the only player on the team I liked. And fuck Kobe, I hate that whiny bitch.
      Wino, I don’t know of anyone that is a Lakers fan but hates Kobe. That’s a first :)

      • Burgundy LaRue

        I’m in the same position as Wino–loved the Lakers as a kid, but can’t deal with Kobe’s divo ways. I wanted him to be traded instead of Shaquille O’Neal a few years, though I knew that wouldn’t happen and realized it made no sense to get rid of a guy that hadn’t even reached his prime at that point. But for all his faults, Shaq is basically a decent guy. Kobe is 100% jerk.

  • pattyluponey

    Sadly, I quit reading after you mentioned the new-fangled 90210, because 1) I am the same age…and 2) I didn’t realize the Silver connection until you mentioned it, but SO TRUE!!!!!

    I have to say SYTYCD has become the fast track to a professional career, if only because the dancers are recognizable. BUT, you must be talented to make it in the first place, so…all Idol comparisons are mute…

    Mark Kanemura came in 5th…yet may be one of the best dancers to come out of SYTYCD….just saying…

    Also, I disagree with Neil’s categorization. All of his professional credits are in musical theatre, so shouldn’t he be labeled Broadway? (As if Broadway is an all-emcompassing genre , reality television?)