... ...

Holy Toledo why were they knocking off Banksy? AI9 Top 3 Results

2010 May 20

This recap may be a day late and a dollar short, but hey, that’s the story of my life.

Am I looking forward to watching this? Hell no. Set aside, for a moment, the fact Our Beloved Goatboy was sent home (He wasn’t given much to work with last night, so…), because that’s not it. Justin Bieber (aka the Imp of Hades) is here. Some yahoo named Travis Garland is here — by way of Perez fucking Hilton. Perez fucking Hilton. Perez fucking Hilton is honestly a person I would not mind getting run over by a Mack truck.

All those eliminated before are sitting in the audience. I barely remember anyone since Andrew Garcia. Seacrest sits Casey, Crystal and Les DeWeewee down on the sofa for a chitty chat in the vein of Edward R. Murrow. At one time, Les DeWeewee’s general apathy towards the proceedings seemed a lot like the need to vomit. Lately, it seems to be leaning more towards the possibility he could be a big ol’ self-absorbed asshat.

The contestants talk about their journeys back home. Mark my words — this season will be the first season they allow the contestants to perform original music on the tour, namely Crystal Bowersox’s Holy Toledo. Les DeWeewee rambles on a bit like Danny Gokey, the man responsible for 1/3 his DNA. Casey James seems to let Bowersox and DeWeewee to carry the conversation since he pretty much accepted the fact he would be killed him off tonight. Bowersox is press savvy — son, diabetes, the Lord.

Randy Jackson is allowed to talk. Is there a case for getting him a court-appointed guardian who would be responsible for not only setting ground rules on anything he says, but also for purchasing his eyewear? Randy talks about how the contestants have grown because of Idol and their guidance. Casey James just starts laughing. He’s grinning ear to ear. Homeboy does not give a shit at this point and its impossible not to love him for it.

I was just thinking, not every single comment was usable.

Oh, cameraman, doing the pre-commercial break closeup on Bowersox and then realizing it should be on Casey, as his homecoming will be seen next. Tsk tsk. That save was not very stealthy, but you’re probably just doing what you’re told. I get it. Everyone needs a paycheck.

I’m tired. Can I stop writing now?

FORD COMMERCIAL MAYHEM

The director of this week’s Ford commercial, set to Wild One, is likely some fresh young thing who thought, you know what is totally edgy and happening right now? Banksy. Let’s give this week’s spot a real Banksy edge.

I know Les DeWeewee is holding up the stencil so his fellow Banksy wannabes can put the finishing touches on the green Ford Fiesta before anyone sees them, but I like to think he’s pissing on the wall. Our boy Les seems like the type to piss on another person’s art. He kind of does that every week.

HOMECOMING: CASEY JAMES

As soon as Casey yells TEXAS from the private jet, I think I might like him more. Although I do feel bad for him playing up the fact he doesn’t have a girlfriend. He really doesn’t know what’s in store for him, does he? The frauen. They will eat him alive, but I think Les DeWeewee has more. And this woman, well, she had Casey sign her dog but she might be totally harmless. Unless she tattoos the signature into her puppy’s ass so he is branded forever.

Casey gets the Dallas Cowboy Cheerleaders. And school girls. And a bunch of frauen. But he also says HOLY SHIT and it has to be bleeped. I like it. He said shit. Casey takes his exquisite momma Bybee with him to the hospital that saved his life after the motorcycle accident. Bybee is in tears and clutches the Good [& Hot] Dr. Corey Collinge while Casey bequeaths to him/the hospital a signed guitar.

Remember Mimi from The Drew Carey Show? I think she even came out to cheer on Casey James.

Also, can someone tell me why American Idol uses good music for narration, yet they no one can ever do these songs on the show?

Next up is Travis Garland, but before he performs, Seacrest gets to talk to Perez fucking Hilton aka the guy who championed Lady Gaga and Katy Perry. Oh please. He did not DISCOVER them. I don’t care if the bastard is getting Sony money now, he’s not some sort of sage/prophet/svengali. He’s a fucking douchebag who is the disgrace of the blogosphere. And all living creatures. It’s good to know he can probably only get laid if he pays for it.

Perez fucking Hilton thinks Travis Garland — who covered T.I. (not me) and Justin Timberlake in his bedroom and filmed it one day — is EVEN BETTER THAN JUSTIN TIMBERLAKE.

Who the hell is this Toolie Garfield loser? Did someone kick him in the nuts before he went on stage? Our Beloved Frances, the Patron Saint of Hollywood, says Travis Garland has a big ass mole and that he was in some boy band called NLT that also had some dude in a wheelchair. The dancers. The paper-thin reediness of this kid’s voice. The song lacking both conviction, coherence and any discernible melody. Alas. Another gigantic fail for Perez fucking Hilton. (BTW, doesn’t everyone know there is only ONE Mole Idol? Quatto, bitches. Don’t forget it.)

This might be the longest American Idol episode in history. Do you get the feeling Seacrest just loves to utter the words Justin Bieber?

HOMECOMING: CRYSTAL BOWERSOX

This season may suck beyond belief, but Crystal Bowersox will forever remain one of my all-time favorite contestants. She’s fun! She’s talented! She doesn’t give a shit.

I just whomped that girl with a flower.

Michael Bell, the mayor of Toledo, naturally gives Crystal a KEY TO THE CITY! Michael Bell reminds me that Idol Homecomings always introduce us to at least one seemingly kick ass mayor.

Crystal’s song Holy Toledo is so damn good, they’re even using it as part of the soundtrack. And she’s got her old band with her. Hooray, folks! The band’s back together. You can’t not adore Crystal. Or her band. Or her biker father. Don’t you just want to hang out and smoke pot with Crystal Bowersox?

Crystal Bowersox. Just too damn good for this shit show, however, regardless what happens next week, things will work out amazingly well for this one. She’s special, mainly because she will never become what Idol wants her to be. She also cares about Northwest Ohio and is overcome with emotion that Holy Toledo has become an anthem for her city — and that they actually played it on American fucking Idol. Like I said, I bet she will be performing it on the tour, but hell, how is this girl gonna do with a set-in-stone set list every damn night?

HOMECOMING: LEE DEWYZE

Why the hell does Les DeWeewee get Edward Sharpe & The Magnetic Zeroes’ AMAZING Home for his theme song? People scream for him. He gets to throw out the first pitch at a Chicago Cubs game (they lost, btw). Kids at an elementary school cheer for him.

Lee seems genuinely touched at his reception. Particularly at the paint store. He cries. He kind of reminds me of Jamie Oliver when he cries because the children are eating Tostino’s Party Pizzas for breakfast. BREAKFAST DAMMIT BREAKFAST.

I’m gonna try to win the thing, ALRIGHT.

Ok. He sounds rather annoyed? That was either humorous or…this one is tough. I really want to like this guy, even though I suspect I cannot stand him. He sounds better during his at-home performances, but hey, the pressure is off — Casey James knocked it out of the park back in Texas. DeWeewee getting genuinely choked up during I am leaving / I am leaving / But the fighter still remains almost fraking gets to me and I feel both dirty and manipulated. Luckily, before I can succumb to full-on parental-love manipulation tactics, I become fixated on DeWeewee’s TOO LONG NECKTIE and all is right with the world once again.

Lee DeWyze will win American Idol. And I’ll be okay with it. Why? Well first off, I don’t give a rat’s ass about the show. Second, he will finally be the guy to tell his frauen to step the frak off. I’m almost rubbing my hands with anticipation right now.

Seacrest gets to say Justin Bieber again. And as if tonight couldn’t get more excruciating, the Moppet of Beelzebub gets to sing TWO songs. Perhaps its a medley. Is anyone waiting for his voice to crack a la Peter Brady in that song about one has to rearrange when its time to change?

What can I say about Bieber? He’s a lot better than Travis Garland. The song Baby would be really catchy and cool if I didn’t have any taste. It just sounds like a T-Mobile commercial to me for some reason. And the kid still sort of sometimes screams date rapist to me, although I’m sure they’re just coaching him to look that way.

Drum solo. Pyrotechnics. It’s okay, Casey James. I would be wanting to get the hell out by now, too.

First person in next week’s finale? Duh. Lee DeWyze. That Les DeWeewee isn’t really a hugger. He likes to celebrate by himself, perhaps. Or he’s a douchebag. Ever the sweetheart, Crystal Bowersox asks if she’s safe before hugging Casey and saying keep playing. (She then goes to hug Les, so I guess he’s okay with his personal space being violated sometimes.) Casey seems okay with the way things went down. Hey, he got his homecoming. He’ll probably get a record deal out of it. Sadly, the poor thing is forced to do Daughters as his swan song. Casey, also the sweetheart, goes around the audience and puts his arm around some pretty young things, even picks up his little niece or family friend, some girl who wore the entire ribbon section of Michael’s on her head. He goes a little goaty on his encore. But come on, the song sucks. And who doesn’t LOVE GOATS?

You know Kara DioGuardi slipped him her private phone number once the credits rolled, right? But that Casey James, that good ol’ boy has some class. Hell, its probably why he finished third.

Spread the word. Do it.
[Facebook] [Google] [Reddit] [StumbleUpon] [Twitter] [Yahoo!] [Email]
  • muzikizmi

    Richard Rushfield just tweeted this, and it is such an interesting theory, I had to share.

    “richardrushfield After saying lee wins for weeks am now buying @adambvary theory he is bo bice: made to seem legit contender as the b’sox is so far ahead”

    • suew

      I think thats an interesting theory and could be true, but what about dialidol showing Lee to be ahead of Crystal on last week’s show? Alot of people also think Lee is a legit contender.

      • http://topidolblog.com TopIdol

        Sue, I agree with you 100%. And honestly, I see Lee winning the whole damn thing.

        • muzikizmi

          I agree that Lee is ahead. I just found Adam B. Vary’s theory to be interesting. Lee has been getting all of the praise lately. It will be interesting to see if that continues on Tuesday.

          • Mithra

            Dial Idol has been inaccurate for the last couple seasons because of texts. I think Lee’s got the text vote being that the larger percentage is thought to be teens.

            Crystal should come out wearing a studded codpiece and call it “The Bowerbulge” – only way to fight that peen factor ;)

      • Burgundy LaRue

        I thought about that angle too, but unless proven otherwise, I have a hard time buying it. I don’t recall Carrie getting the de-pimped treatment. Crystal has, albeit subtly. TPTB will hedge their bets in case Crystal pulls off the win, but this feels like a confetti drop in Lee’s favor.

  • Mithra

    I clicked on the youtube of Crystal singing at 13 (which is now featured with a big pic on yahoo’s front page) and scrolled down to see this lovely comment:

    start singing at the age of 13? adam lambert start singer when hewas 10 years old adma axting and signer in los sneles plus singing in europe.
    a true gifted signer name; elvis presley-michael jackson and adam lambert. remember thyre the same zodiac sign animal(mj-elvis and adam) and madonna as well;
    cyrstal bowersox same as kris zodiac animal sign ox year born.

    :D

    • LittleMissCynic

      Wow. I am blown away by the intelligence displayed in that comment.

      • LittleMissCynic

        Oh and also, I am a Horse. A quick little trip to google told me that Paul McCartney, Aretha Franklin, and Barbara Streisand are also Horses. I think you all know where I’m going with that…

        ;)

        • jukejoint

          I’m a minkey. A FIRE minkey.

          Me and Diana Ross and Johnny Cash. And Julius Caesar (!), Leonardo DaVinci, Bette Davis, Elizabeth Taylor and Eleanor Roosevelt. Also Celine Dion and Christina Aguilera, but I don’t like either of them, so I don’t care.

    • nerdgirl

      So, if some Sparkle Cows like Lee, are they going to wear plaid? But it will be sparkly paid. Or it will say “It’s not Kurs Alien plaid”. Or will their heads explode.
      It’s gonna be interesting

      • Mithra

        What’s even funnier is that Krusty Onions is and Ox, so why do the sparkle cows hate him so?

        So I guess this means Crystal is going to win, right? They didn’t say what Lee was. A tree sloth?

        • jukejoint

          Lee is a tiger (she says, after a very cursory glance at the internet). His co-tigers include Stevie Wonder, Jon Bon Jovi and Paula Abdul.

          Oxen include both Paul Newman and Robert Redford, as well as Meryl Streep, Barack Obama, Johann Sebastian Bach and Bruce Springsteen. 2009 was a “Year of the Ox,” which would explain Curs Alien taking Idol in 2009, I guess. It wasn’t AT&T and Chik-Fil-A — it was all the Chinese Zodiac’s fault!

          2010 is the Year of the Tiger, so I guess that means Lee wins. What a shame. I thought we got to vote.

          • nerdgirl

            I am a tiger, I hope I win and not Lee…

          • MaryS-NJ

            Huh, I’m a tiger (water – 1962) too. I CAN HAZ WHOLE GAZELLE? NOM NOM NOM

            Nevertheless, since my favorite Dog was just given the boot, I will vote for the Ox.

    • On The Edge

      Huh, no wonder Kris and Crystal apeal to me…I’m an Ox, too!

      • On The Edge

        APPEAL, damn it.

      • et

        Hmm, I’m an Ox, too. And I like Curses Alien and Crystal, too. Hmmm!

        • Miz

          I’m a snake can I like Kris and Crystal too? … and my name is …. well, I won’t say, but I like their names.

          • Miz

            Oh, and I’m compatible with Ox and Rooster (waves, Lauren)

      • Nich

        I’m a Ram, what does that say about me?

        • Nich

          Oh and I like Kris and Crystal.

          • On The Edge

            Well, since now everybody wants to know their Chinese horoscope, here ya go: http://www.chinesezodiac.com/

          • ross

            I’m a dog.

          • jukejoint

            ross are a true gifted signer name; elvis presley-michael jackson and ross. remember thyre the same zodiac sign animal(mj-elvis and ross) and madonna as well; are dog all

          • ross

            jukejoint, thank me very much for these infos. I were in aughust companies.

          • Lauren

            GUYS I’M A COCK!!!!! xD I love saying that.

            But guess what google told me? I am compatible with oxen! SCORE!

    • suew

      Can someone tell me why it is necessary to insert the name of Adam Lambert on every single idol blog on every single thread?

  • suew

    According to the la times, melissa e can’t perform on idol this year because she was on dwts. As for lee, I never saw anywhere that he even likes nickelback. Why do people keep saying nickelback for lee? Cause its a joke of a band?

    Lee does like dave matthews and kings of leon. Maybe he can song kol’s sex on fire or whatever its called.

    • Nich

      Nickelback IS a joke of a band but I say Nickelback because to me that’s the type of sound he has.

      • suew

        I agree that nickelback sucks, but I think lee sounds more like dave matthews or rob thomas. I remember people used to compare cook to creed and nickelback and his fans would freak, but to me cook does sound like them.

        How about a bruce springsteen/dewyze duet?

        • jukejoint

          But he performed Hinder. Hinder is in the same (drekky) box as Nickelback and he chose to perform Hinder the second week of the competition. That’s the impression he left. He’s never performed anything by Dave Matthews or Rob Thomas (who are, btw, nothing like each other IMO). Or anything by Springsteen.

          There is no way Springsteen will be coming on American Idol. He let That Old Devil Clive use “Dancing in the Dark” for Taylor Hicks, but other than Steven Van Zandt appearing in the audience (and being pals with David Cook), Springsteen has shown no inclination to be in any way associated with this show.

          Maybe Seal. Or Owl City. Or Snow Patrol. The Fray? He’s sung stuff by all of them.

          But I doubt it’ll be anybody that current. The last alt-rock boy got ZZ Top.

          • vtu

            Yeah, between Hinder and that dippy Fireflies song, Lee lost me altogether two weeks into the competition. The man clearly has absolutely no taste in music.

            I do think that he may be an ideal candidate for TPTB, though, in that since he doesn’t seem to know good music from bad, they’ll probably have decent luck getting him to sing whatever dreck they think will sell well and play well on radio.

          • On The Edge

            I thought Lee might get Paul Simon, on a duet of “The Boxer,” but I don’t see him doing Idol…maybe they’ll get Art Garfunkle?

          • Miz

            Springsteen would be great but I’d doubt they’d get him. AI’s lighting designer was (maybe still is) the Boss’s tour designer.

            I’ve always wanted a Paul Simon week and have him mentor.

          • http://topidolblog.com TopIdol

            Springsteen would never happen. Nor should he. Springsteen is a god.

          • suew

            I was being sarcastic with my springsteen comment – I agree with you. There are certain people who would NEVER appear on idol – springsteen and Ed Vedder/Pearl Jam are two who come to mind.

    • mozart4898

      Lol not that this really matters, but to me, Nickelback and Creed are post-grunge. Hinder is pop-rock. Quite a difference to me – I really think that Nickelback and Creed’s songs tend to be driven more by a guitar riff than a vocal hook (like Hinder). Lee is closer to Hinder than the other two. Actually though I still think he’s even closer to a John Mayer type (singer-songwriter, light-rock).

    • Miz

      OK, is AI that vindictive that they won’t have someone who performed on DWTS on it’s show? Ut oh! They used Kris Allen’s LLWD on that show. I hope they forget that or they’ll pull him from the Finale.

  • Mithra

    this season will be the first season they allow the contestants to perform original music on the tour, namely Crystal Bowersox’s Holy Toledo.

    Blake Lewis did an original at the very end of the tour. You’re right though, it would be interesting to see if they let them do original songs, and who they let do it…

    • mozart4898

      For me (for you), the fact that they used Holy Toledo in her homecoming video said one big thing – they (TPTB) think that it’s a good enough song to be put out there for the general public. The fact they’d acknowledge that is, I think, huge. After all, if they’re all about controlling pretty much everything the Idols do, using a song that was 100% created by a contestant (no co-writer, no studio musicians, nothing like that) is a VERY surprising move. It makes you stop and think, when all the people say that they don’t really want Crystal to win. If they didn’t – would they actually promote her own music like that then? Seems to me they’re playing on Lee’s marketability…but aware of Crystal’s real potential and possibly looking for the best of both worlds.

      • Mithra

        Remember the pics of the duets, and theirs looked like, as someone here pointed out, like the cover of a vintage 60′s folk album? Perhaps they are trying to save money, will call it a draw, and make them form a duo and cut costs…

      • Burgundy LaRue

        Absolutely. When it comes to the Final 2, Idol will almost always hedge their bets. Lee may win, but if they think they can make money off Crystal, then she’ll get some promotion, too. Count on that.

  • Trish

    Hey, did you see that Jon Hamm will be on Ellen next week, along with Crystal and DeWeezie?

    Casey was all kinds of awesome on Ellen and in that press conference. Does anybody believe he’d really work with that bitch Kara? As if Mama James would ever let THAT happen!

  • Nich

    Just wanted to drop this in here, pretty good Casey interview with EW. He’s so matter of fact and laid back. I liked this part:

    You sound like a really humble guy. What’s it been like dealing with this new mass of lusty fans — because it’s a much larger group that you’d find in any bar of intoxicated people?
    You just keep in mind that it’s a situation that’s built up. It is what it is. If it wasn’t me, it would be someone else and people would be freaking out about them at all. I don’t take it as, Look how cool I am. Everybody loves me. I hope those people continue to be my fans musically, and if they do then hopefully at that point I’ll have to keep my ego in check [laughs]. But at this point, there is none because I realize it’s a situational deal. You know what I mean by that?

    Damn you Casey! Don’t make me like you.

    • Dickory Dock

      See, this is what I keep saying. Over the course of the season he made it impossible to hate on him. And then he made it impossible not to actually like him.

      That’s a damn fine answer he gave there, by the way. Seems to have his wits about him.

      • vtu

        I was just thinking the same thing. We had some hints earlier that he might be a himbo, but it turns out he may have a pretty good head on his shoulders.

    • ross

      Smart guy. I like him even more now.

      • Miz

        Me too, Ross. They screwed his head on right after that motorcycle accident.

        • maturin

          Hee. You know what was pervy? I though Casey looked hot in that old shot of him hospitalized after his accident on the danged donorbike (as a cruel surgeon of my acquaintance called them).

          Imma vote for Crystal, still lurve her music a whole lot more, but Casey comes across as a super nice, level headed dude in those interviews.

  • Nich

    I wonder who they have lined up for the finale show. First off I wonder if Casey will get to do a solo performance and who will he perform with. Alison got to perform with Cyndi Lauper, Elliot with Mary J. Blige, Daughtry with Live, and Melinda with the Winans.

    Seeing who they put the final two with is always interesting. Archie was with one Republic while Cook got ZZ Top which was fun but odd. Adam got Kiss and Kris got Keith Urban. I’m betting they get Melissa Etheridge for Crystal but who will they get for Lee?

    • Pandora

      Nickelback?

      • Nich

        Oh boy, I bet. Maybe they could go one better and have Nickelback AND Hinder duet with Lee.

        • Dickory Dock

          And then I gouge my eyes out with a rusty spoon while bleeding from my ears. Good times.

        • et

          Maybe they could go one better and have Nickelback AND Hinder duet with Lee.

          That might cause me to perforate my own eardrums in protest.

    • jukejoint

      I think I saw somewhere that Melissa Etheridge said she will not be on the finale. Maybe Jewel for Crystal? She is definitely amenable to cheesy reality TV shows, since she and husband did Dancing with the Stars. Well, she got injured. But she *tried* to do Dancing with the Stars.

      Given how much they seem to care, they’ll probably have Hinder for Lee and the Jonas Bros for Crystal.

      • Trish

        Jewel was a judge on that epically awful Nashville Star as well. The one that Billy Ray Cyrus hosted (and where he introduced his daughter to that that dumb-as-a-box-of-rocks Justin Gaston).

        Lee actually likes some very cool musicians. Maybe they can get Art Garfunkel to sing with him. I don’t think Yusef (b/k/a Cat Stevens) would EVER do American Idol!

    • Pandora

      I actually think Melissa Etheridge might be too obvious for Crystal, especially since she sang Come To My Window this week. What about Alanis Morisette or Annie Lennox? Or if they were a little bit creative and didn’t only think of pairing her with other women, what about John Fogerty? That would be un-fricking-believable.

      I think the Goo Goo Dolls have a new album, so they may bring them in for Lee which would suck since the GGDs are actually decent, unlike Nickelback. But Nickelback has an album out too, so they’d want to pimp themselves, so…

      • jukejoint

        John Mellencamp is who I think would be perfect for Crystal to duet with.

        • mozart4898

          Crystal could probably really work with anyone. Seriously. I was thinking about it…Jewel, Etheridge (who we know it won’t be), Fogerty…heck, how about Paul McCartney? Elton John? I could even see Carrie Underwood. Jeff Beck. Five for Fighting. I have trouble thinking of good singers/musicians that I don’t think she’d work well with.

        • Blue Eyes

          I would love a duet with Crystal and Sheryl Crow! Or Crystal and Bonnie Raitt!

          • maturin

            I think a team up between Crystal and Sheryl Crowe would be amazing. I still shudder at the memory of the VH1 Diva show last year where Melissa Etheridge dueted with Kelly Clarkson (total love) and Sheryl was paired with Miley Fucking Cyrus.

            Sheryl is OWED an awesome duet, which Crystal would provide!!!

  • TankieGirlie

    “Also, can someone tell me why American Idol uses good music for narration, yet they no one can ever do these songs on the show?”

    Question of the ages!

    • Trish

      I know. They used an Elbow song on Casey’s hometown visit video!

      • mozart4898

        Hmmmmmm…imagining Crystal getting Fortunate Son as her producer’s pick next week…

        I think that’d be amazing.

  • TankieGirlie

    I give you Beiber vs Revolving Door

  • smashemup

    OK. I am not from the US and I have never seen Perez Hilton before (heard of it though) but geez, he looks like Herman Munster.

  • Lucky

    The picture of the little boy at Lee’s homecoming is perfect. I put my fingers in my ears when Lee sings too. Great re-cap as usual TI.

  • suew

    Since the comments section is usually where people go on about the ‘unfairness’ of things with respect to their favorite contestant, I’m surprised noone mentioned that Crystal’s homecoming bit included an original song and Lee’s did not.

    Or maybe there just aren’t any Lee fans here. And Lee is DEFINTELY not a dbag like people are making him out to be – he seems to be a genuine, humble guy who can’t believe his good fortune. In fact, by ALL accounts of eliminated contestants and others who know him, he is a kind, down-to-earth guy with a hilarious personality. His nerves prevent him from showing the personality on the show.

    I was voting for Crystal, but I’m switching now to Lee. Too much undeserved anger directed at him. Plus, I’m from Chicago.

    Go Lee for the win!

    *runs away before gets attacked*

    • auntieaimee

      I think they used Crystal’s song because it was about her hometown. If Lee wrote a song about his hometown, maybe they would have used it.

    • Dickory Dock

      I still vote douchebag. Or tool. Either one will work. :|

      As far as fair treatment, really? Because he’s been coddled all season long and any vocal imperfections have been glossed over while the judges tell him he’s still teh awesome and ZOMG just a PAINT SALESMAN from Chicago!!!1!1

      I find it impossible to work up even the tiniest soupçon of sympathy for the dude.

      • suew

        I don’t think its a big deal, just wanted to mention it because people generally point out the unfairness on other contestants. Obviously the producers/judges wanted Lee to be in the finale, they see something marketable in him. Its all about the money.

        Its not Lees fault that Simon likes him. Whats he supposed to say, thanks for the praise but I don’t deserve it? Heap it on someone more deserving, like goat vibrato instead? Cause the cougars like him?

        • Dickory Dock

          Lee’s been unfairly pimped all season. Not his fault, but nevertheless offputting. Just my take. I liked him better when he looked like he was about to vomit every 10 seconds, but whatevia.

          Heh. Never said Goat Boy should have been pimped. If pimpery is deserved, pimpery should be given. Much of Lee’s has been undeserved because for some reason Simon’s got an Il Divo sized boner for him. Again, just my take.

          • wino

            still not sure why Simon is favoring him so much. at best, he’s second rate Cook/Daughtry. im having flashbacks to last year, when simon inexplicably lauded Gokey after every bad performance. having said that, I do like his recording voice and out of the many possiblities, a Lee and MammaSox finale is our best option for a good finale show.

      • Blue Eyes

        What douchebaggery has Lee done?

        I think judges have gone with him because he’s more marketable. They don’t want another “Taylor Hicks” year.

        • Pandora

          How is a guy who can’t sing live, has no charisma, and no performance ability marketable?

          • Blue Eyes

            Two word…pop/rock. It’s what sells. Daughtry. Nickelback, David Cook, Bon Jovi. All you need is pop/rock and raspy voice and it sells.

          • jukejoint

            I think there’s a huge difference between Taylor and Casey and their brand of blues. Casey has never claimed to be a throwback to Ray Charles. He’s more country blues and I’d like to see T-Bone Burnett take him under his wing. That folk/blues/bluegrass junction would be great for Casey.

            Honestly, I’m not sure any one of these three is marketable. Or even anybody in the Top 10. Maybe Tim Urban in a Jonas Brothers slice of the market, or Didi, if they could’ve pushed her into a more pop-alt/Vanessa Carlton/Erin McCarley direction. Not sure how much money that direction is making, but that’s kind of the best of the bunch.

            New Jewel-Meets-Melissa-Etheridge sounds cool, but I’m not sure America wants to buy that album.

            New Hinder/Nickelback sounds marketable because the other ones are, but do we need another one when the current ones seem to be slipping and we already have Daughtry and Cook doing that? (Or maybe the idea that Hinder/Nickelback is slipping is just wishful thinking on my part.)

            Honestly, I think they picked not-that-marketable people from top to bottom this year and I have no idea why. Katie whatsername? Paige? Siobhan? Michael Lynche? What do you do with any of them when it comes to cutting a record?

          • auntieaimee

            jukejoint, all good points. I agree.

        • Dickory Dock

          You are so right. He’s totally marketable.

          Whereas this guy

          Is a woeful lameass who totally blows.

          Sorry, but that guitar playing made my eyes goggle out of their sockets for a minute.

          • et

            I vastly enjoyed Casey’s Ellen performance :)

          • Blue Eyes

            I personally think he’s awesome, but that’s the kind of music Taylor Hicks sings and we all know what happened to him. Blues just does not sell. He also needs to control the vibrato a little better.

          • http://topidolblog.com TopIdol

            I think what might separate him from Hicks is the guitar skills and lack of gray hair / spastic dancing?

          • sj

            Casey also seems to be much more laid back than Taylor. I like that in a personality:)

            I’ve always felt kind of bad for Taylor Hicks. I don’t know much about him, but he seems to be much maligned by the “media”. I guess it’s the chance you take when you set yourself up to be the subject of brutal ridicule or obsessive adoration when the gamble is to just win some good fans. One thing’s for sure: AI contestants have balls of steel.

          • wino

            wow, his voice is pretty good on this video and like always, sick guitar playing. too bad blues doesnt sell as well as pop, i rather listen to that on my radio than KeSha’s blah blah blahs.

          • kimberly

            Wow! My son’s been trying to master the blues for a couple of years now. He’s 16 and has been taking guitar for 6 years. I had him watch the video and he was duly impressed. Casey seemed almost bouyant, less restrained. Idol can really suck the life out of people. He’ll find his niche and will do well. The guy has talent.

          • Dickory Dock

            I read an article about Casey at MTV (shut up) where they interviewed a guy he used to play with. He said Casey is self taught, just by spending hours and hours with the guitar. I’ll admit I boggled, because if it’s true that’s just all kinds of crazy.

          • Nich

            Wow! He was really good there. Every time someone tells me that he is a crap guitar player (seriously) I want to play them this bit. I thought he was funny with the drinking from the cup bit and I liked how he explained why he didn’t think he’d win.

          • ross

            I hate the way Lee reacts to getting into Top 2.

    • et

      Do you know Lee personally? I don’t know if he’s a douchebag or not but I wouldn’t go so far as to say anyone is *definitely* anything unless I know them personally.

      • suew

        No, I don’t know him personally. I am relying on accounts from former contestants, friends, people he worked with, etc. Every single former contestant had positive things to say about him. I’m not sure how anybody gets the impression that he is a douchebag? Did he do something specifically to you to make you think that? Were you guys dating and he broke up with you?

        • et

          People *think* he’s a douchebag just like you *think* he’s not. Perception and all that. And NO I wasn’t dating him, he comes up to my shoulder and I don’t find anything attractive about him, lol.

          • suew

            You made me laugh! Which is why I come to this board to being with!

    • Mithra

      I agree with you suew. I don’t get where the douchebag label is coming from, except from fan warring mentality of those with other favorites.

      As for the original song issue, Maybe he should have written one called “Little Moan From Mount Prospect” ;)

      • Dickory Dock

        It’s not a fanwar thing. The problem is that we have no Gokey this year. We are trying to Gokey-ize Lee. He comes across as a schleppy dude with a possible streak of douchenozzle (plus he sang Hinder, so there’s that) so we run with it. Eh.

        • Mithra

          He’s just so there, so kinda boring. I find people drawing up the effort up to hate funny. He wouldn’t even muster up half the energy, which is probably why he never puked on stage even though it looked like he would. Too much trouble.

      • jukejoint

        I don’t have a favorite. I haven’t since, oh, whatsername with the curly blonde hair. Katelyn. Her, I kind of liked. Oh, and I thought John Park had potential. I like the ones who seem smart. The rest of this bunch, not so much. But just because I don’t have a horse in this race doesn’t mean I have to think Lee is anything special. I don’t. I do think he comes off as a douchenozzle. In making this judgment, I bring all of my life experiences and people-watching skills to bear on what lumpy suburban Chicago boys who drop out of high school for punching people are like. I went to high school with these people. Just down the road from Prospect H.S.! I even went to Prospect for speech competitions. Which should tell you right there that I am the absolute opposite of the Lee DeWyzes of the world. Nerd = me. I like and always liked smart, nerdy boys. My boyfriend was on the chess team. Lee = Boy in Leather Jacket Who Smoked Outside the School and Kept Setting Garbage Cans on Fire and Tried to Beat Up My Chess Club Boyfriend. Or mocked me mercilessly for my Muffy Tepperman ways. Why would I like him? Sure, people can change. But Lee doesn’t seem any different from the surly, socially inept high school boy who got expelled. I’ve yet to see an appealing facial expression on him. What, I’m supposed to set aside everything I know about the world and the people in it just because somebody on an interet forum tells me I should? Nope. I trust my own judgment more than yours.

        And Lee just strikes me as a lump. And not in a good way, like a sugar lump. No. More like a douchnozzle bumpkin thick-headed schlemiel lump. Who is the psychic brother of all the lumps who mocked me in high school and I’m still carrying a grudge. Shrug. That’s how we do these things. We watch people on TV, we compare them to the template of all the people we’ve known before, and we decide if we like them or not. I don’t like Lee. Game over.

        • maturin

          I do think he comes off as a douchenozzle. In making this judgment, I bring all of my life experiences and people-watching skills to bear on what lumpy suburban Chicago boys who drop out of high school for punching people are like.

          The deadpan of this comment cracked my shit up.

        • suew

          jukejoint, I really like your post, but I disagree with your asessment of Lee. The trouble in high school, according to articles (not me), stemmed from him standing up for a boy who was being picked on. He had the nerve to tell the other guy to lay off, and ended up getting in a fistfight over it. I find that really admirable, especially considering the age – it seems that most teenage boys would either look the other way or join in. Its my understanding that he told school officials he couldn’t function within the confines of the school, and it was more of his decision to go to the alternative school than theirs.

          He might not be a brainy nerd, but he has a heart. I don’t see nything in him that would be beating up the little guy, rather STANDING up for the chess club guy. Instead of being the “mocker” he was the guy who stepped in when others got mocked and stood up for them. Just my opinion based on what I’ve read.

    • Trish

      Not a Lee fan, but was wondering the same thing. Maybe if he’d written a song with “Chicago” in the lyric? I dunno. That “Holy Toledo” song is pretty awesome and it was perfect for the video. I wouldn’t be surprised if Lee gets to do some original music at some point on the show or on tour, though.

      • mozart4898

        I think the reason why they wouldn’t have used any of Lee’s originals on his homecoming video was pretty clear. They used The Boxer…but they didn’t even use Lee’s version! What does that tell you? They realize he’s not as good. Using a Lee original and a Crystal original would have invited direct comparions, and I’m betting they didn’t want that. So instead, they used mostly the original version of The Boxer in his video, then showed the clip at the end of his hometown performance of it where he was obviously emotional. Bingo. You feel for him, and you don’t notice how good or bad his singing really is.

  • saffergirl

    So this is only my second comment, but I just had to come out and declare my absolute love for Mamasox. Up until this results show, the only thing I felt was a total disliking for Lee. I was hoping for a Crystal/Casey final because I kinda liked them but more because i just could not stand to see Lee win. I tried really hard to feel something for these contestants, but thought maybe I was immune after Kris. Last night it FINALLY struck whilst watching Crystals homecoming package. In those few minutes, she won my complete adoration. I couldn’t believe how likable she was and her humility shone through so brightly. I love how she handles this newfound fame. And “Holy Toledo” was AMAZING, she would’ve pulvarized Lee if they had been allowed to perform originals on tuesday night. Like you said, she’s special. So very, very special. I’m not sure I can handle seeing her lose to Lee-selfabsorbed- dewyze next week, and I know it’s coming. This was a stunning recap, btw, somehow your blog always makes me feel a little better….

    • Trish

      Yeah, I’d liked “Mamasox” (HATE that name) but lost interest in her until her hometown package, but that was really awesome. And then I saw that video of her performing at age 13. She’s brilliant. I will vote for her next week unless she throws the whole thing.

  • Dickory Dock

    Does Lee DeWheezy seem to get douchier and douchier, or is it just me?

    Farewell, beloved Goat Boy. You knew your number was up and were cool with it. Way to cockblock Kara during your sing out – take Ellen’s hand, fist bump Randy, shrug all WTF at Kara. Well played, son. Well played.

    Also, the Mayor of Cool, Texas is pretty awesome if only for the ten gallon and handlebar:

    Image and video hosting by TinyPic

    I like Crystal. Holy Toledo is a fantastic song, and the fact that she was moved to tears hearing played on Idol warmed my icy heart. I would love her to win, but I think Lee is the winner they deserve. Heh.

    Fuck you, Perez Hilton. You are a maggot. That is all.

    • Trish

      He *is* cool, but nobody is more awesome than the mayor of Toledo!

  • http://Twitter Anniepg

    I’m from Toledo. There are a lot of cool people living here. Yeah, our mayor rides a Harley and wears black leather. We love Crystal and that she remains true to her roots. Just you watch; Crystal has a lot more to write and sing!

    Toledo has been in an economic funk. Crystal has been an inspiration and reminded us that anything is possible.

    I’ll be voting my fingers to the bone for Crystal on Tuesday night.

  • auntieaimee

    Ah, closure. There was something about Casey James. He wasn’t the best singer, and he knew it, but that wasn’t what he’s really about. He’s an excellent guitarist who happens to sing. Let’s not forget that he didn’t watch American Idol because he didn’t own a tv. I don’t know. Maybe it was the calm way he took criticsm on the chin, the way he didn’t have a lot to say, but what he did say seemed profound. Maybe it was the way the little girl in the audience immediately stood as he approached and reached her arms way up to hold onto him. I don’t know what it was, but any man beloved by children and doggies has got to be a good guy. He was not the empty headed himbo that the show wanted us to believe he was. Casey, we hardly knew ye, but this was the best outcome for you. Go to Austin, go to Nashville. Get out of LA. Find a small label that will let you do the music you want to do. If your homecoming videos are any indication, I think a lot of folks would be interested in hearing it.

    • Dickory Dock

      He really did win me over throughout the season. If I’m honest, it really impressed me that he never seemed to be playing the game. Anne Powers wrote a decent piece about it at the LA Times Idol Tracker, and talks about Crystal being in the same vein. (She also talks about how Lee is more maliable, which I agree with.) I also think he’s really talented and we only got to see a tiny bit of what he can do on the show.

      Tard moment in 3 … 2 … 1 …

      From an article yesterday:

      There was a rumor that you were going to do a song with more tempo on Tuesday night but had to change it — is that true?

      Things switched up. I’m happy with the way everything turned out, because I love both the songs. Everything was just the way it should have been. I was going to possibly do another song, and then I ended up not. That’s all part of it. That’s the way it goes — that’s just normal operating procedure

      I knew it! Totally sandbagged. And yet? He’s cool about it.

      The rest of the article is here, if anyone’s interested: http://content.usatoday.com/communities/idolchatter/post/2010/05/casey-james-you-dont-always-get-the-chance-to-do-what-you-want-to-do/1

      You will have to copy and paste because I have total html fail.

      • caspar

        Yep. As a Cooktard, I found him the most Cookian by the end. Totally calm, mature, self aware and good humoured. All he lacked was the killer instinct and the vocal chops. Well, and the song choice smarts and the rearranging ability. Prettier hair, though.

        • Dickory Dock

          Caspar, not to bash Cook because I think he’s a decent guy, but it doesn’t take much to beat Cook in the Prettier Hair stakes, you know? ;)

          • caspar

            Very true- hell, Crystal beats Cook in the hair department!

          • et

            I think Cook would be the first to admit that he would not be holding his breath to win any sort of Best Hair prize. He makes fun of his last 15 hairs (or is it 12? I am such a bad tard) often, lol.

          • Mithra

            The hair in Danny Gokey’s ass crack is probably prettier than Cook’s :P

          • Dickory Dock

            Thanks for giving me a mental picture of Gokey’s crack. Off to find brain bleach now.

        • Trish

          Hey, I love Cook. My favorite Idol of all time. But Casey’s every bit as good an instrumentalist as DC is a singer. I loved how Cook played the game to win Idol and was begging the Flying Spaghetti Monstoer for Casey to study David and Kris Allen to learn to play, too. But, in the end, Casey wasn’t willing to sell his soul to that degree, and I love him all the more for it. And I think Casey’s taste in music is about a thousand times better than Cook’s. I love DC *in spite of* some of the dreck he sings and loves.

          Two class acts those dudes. With mamas worthy of crowns of gold.

          • ross

            I can’t figure out why Casey stripped, in his audition, though. Kris or Cook would never have done it. I think it may have cost him votes, even.

          • Trish

            Re the shirt removal, I don’t think he had any idea that was going to end up on television. He’d never watched the show and only auditioned at the last minute because his mother told him to. I think he may have gotten that he was audtioning for a “part” to get to go to Hollywood and realized they were casting a male hunk type. He told a reporter that when he told his mom what he’d done to get to Hollywood, she told him, “You know that’s going to end up on television.” And he was so upset he had to pull off the road. But he made the best of the situation and even now acknoweledges that there was a good chance he wouldn’t have gotten a ticket to Hollywood at all if he hadn’t let down his hair and taken off his shirt. And it’s not like he took his pants off (as far as we know!), for crying out loud!

            I thought he just came off really desperate in that clip, but maybe he was? I think he more than made up for that decision by not playing the “sexay” card all season and at least attempting to show some true musicianship. I really like the dude. He’s a pretty dork is what he is.

          • http://topidolblog.com TopIdol

            Yeah, I’ve kind of forgotten about him ripping off his shirt by this point. In fact, once he played guitar, it seemed kind of a non-factor.

    • ross

      Ah, closure. There was something about Casey James. He wasn’t the best singer, and he knew it, but that wasn’t what he’s really about. He’s an excellent guitarist who happens to sing.

      Eh. So who was the best singer, Lee? Casey’s a good singer, in my opinion. The only time he actually sucked was when he sang Blue Skies, and it was the arrangement. I’m sure he could have sung the Willie Nelson arrangement. Overall, he didn’t have the pitch issues, and what I consider the unpleasant tone (at times) of Lee. So, you say tomato, I say tomahto.

      I don’t know why but it bugs me when you say he’s an excellent guitarist who “happens to sing.” I guess I think he’s better than that. Sorry. I know you meant it in a good way.

      • auntieaimee

        I did mean it as a compliment. I’m not a Lee fan, so I’m in no way arguing that Lee’s better.

        • ross

          I’m not trying to nitpick, I just think he got to third place because he’s a good singer, not a guitar player who happens to sing. He’s a better singer than Tim, Aaaron, and most of the others, to me. His voice is interesting and has character, and he sounds good. I can imagine hearing him on the radio, and not necessarily while hearing his guitar playing. So, yeah, I just think he’s a good singer, I guess.

          • JaneRochester

            Well, he describes himself as a musician who sort of sings, so there’s that. I think he’s a better singer than he thinks he is.

          • vtu

            I agree. He was one of the very few contestants this year who was pretty consistently in tune during his performances (him, Big Mike, and Crystal–hey, look at that, three of the top four). I really like the tone of Casey’s voice. I do think he would benefit from some vocal training to help him control that vibrato a bit more, though.

          • mozart4898

            Laugh all you want, but Timmeh was in tune as much if not more than Casey – he was one of the best intonation-wise of the top 12, right up there with Crystal and Mike (and Tim’s vibrato wasn’t out of control either, plus Tim was an under-rated guitar player himself). That said, Casey’s interpretations and vocal versatility were better – he was just generally more “interesting” as a performer. Mark my words – we’ll hear more from Tim down the road – he may not end up making albums but he will be doing something where music is involved (as people have said, High School Musical or Glee sorts of things).

          • Trish

            I loved Timmy but I gotta disagree that he was in tune more than Casey. And Tim’s phrasing was HORRIBLE. He has a very nice tone to his voice and he seems like a lovely young guy, but to me a great singer requires a general musicality, interpretation skills and breath support that he just doesn’t have yet. I see him much more as a singing actor than a straight singer. Casey to me is a real musician, who plays the guitar and sings.

          • http://topidolblog.com TopIdol

            If we’re talking about being in tune, I would have to agree with Trish. I don’t think the majority of his performances ever had him singing out of tune. You might not like his voice as much as Timmeh’s, but I’m pretty sure key problems weren’t his issue.

  • Verbally Dyslexic

    Thanks for the recap, TI. Your blog is the one bright spark to this dreary season for me. Now however which way it goes, I don’t really care. Like Barado said before (I think), Lee is the winner Idol deserves. But Crystal is the most deserving of votes and regardless of the shiteousness that is 19M, the contract is going to help her do what she said she wanted in the beginning, which is to give her son a good life. So whether she is too good for the show or not, she needs it to get her music career off the ground.

    That said, out of the top 3 this season, I enjoy Casey’s personality and attitude the most. He impressed me with his exit interview.

    The judges complimented Crystal for not compromising herself during the competition. But I don’t think you got enough credit for staying true to yourself.

    I didn’t need to say this out loud, because it was from my own conscience, but going into this, I said to my mom, “More than anything, my self-dignity and my own self-respect is worth more than any amount of money or any kind of fame in the world, and what I’m going to do is I’m going to go out there and be exactly who I am. If they don’t like it, then I won’t get far, but if they do, then I will.” And that’s what I did, and I’m so proud and thankful that I didn’t have to change anything, and that it worked. I mean, I made it to the third position out of a lot of folks that are really talented, and that is one of the things, to be honest with you, that I’m most proud of.

  • wino

    a couple of my ovaries popped when Goat Boy picked up that little girl and sang with/to her. why so purty Casey, why? i still think Lee doesnt have a chance next Tuesday. i’ll bet the votes are in Crystal’s favor and the judges/Simon are trying to create a sense of competition. dont forget, last year Simon BEGGED for votes on behalf of Adam. something tells me Lee needs(needed) the pimpage.

    • On The Edge

      a couple of my ovaries popped

      Um, wouldn’t that be all your ovaries then? I mean we have two…”a couple” implies you have spares… o_O

      I’ll show myself out.

  • et

    Thanks for the recap, TI! It was worth the wait :) Beloved Goat Boy deserved a fitting sendoff. And I hate Perez, I was going to go walk my dog and waited a little too long and caught a glimpse of his smug, smarmy self so then I rushed out — because cleaning up dog poo is *way* better than watching King Douchebag — and I came back too soon and caught the end of the horror that is Travis Garland. Gah.

    And then I walked my dog AGAIN when the Fetus came on because… well, I don’t need no fetus.

    That was cool that they played “Holy Toledo.” Love Crystal. Don’t think she will beat Mr. Schlumpy but I’m voting for her anyway, dammit.

    That show seemed to drag out forever. ForEVER. Even with two doggie walk breaks!!!

  • jukejoint

    I didn’t watch this episode and I honestly don’t care about any of these three. I mean, standing back and looking at them, I would think Crystal is the most like people I listen to and Casey would be the easiest to market if you stick him over the line into country or let him open for Bonnie Raitt (yes, I know that TI doesn’t like her because of “I Can’t Make You Love Me” but girl has done a lot for old blues artists like Sippie Wallace and she really does straddle the line Casey does, like “About to Make Me Leave Home” and “Good Man, Good Woman” with Delbert McClinton. Plus she toured in 2009 with Taj Mahal, the blues musician. Bonnie loves the blues and has done a lot to recognize blues artists.)

    Anyway, my point was that I’m not really into any of these three (or the ones who came before them) but TI’s recap made me feel all sad and melancholy about Crystal and Casey, anyway, and how now Casey is gone and it seems awfully likely that Crystal is gonna lose, too, and maybe she even wants to at this point, because who wants to sell their soul to the devil that is 19 and take what they deign to dole out? But I still feel sad that people’s dreams are dashed every day and that’s life and sometimes we think it doesn’t have to be, that the one(s) we like will get lucky and get to NOT have his or her dreams dashed, and then we are reminded again that, yes, the world is full of Perez Hiltons and Simon Cowells and other people who deserve shit in their Christmas stockings but get champagne wishes and caviar dreams while the nice, sweet, real people get the shit stockings instead, and who wants to constantly be reminded of that sort of sitch? Apparently a lot of people, and they all watch Survivor and the audition episodes of American Idol, and tune in to TMZ and Perez Hilton every chance they get, and maybe even buy copies of Kerry Kolsh’s magnum opus that is, apparently, not quite as magnum as it used to be.

    This makes me sad. Not that Kerry’s opus went on a diet. The other part. I was always a cynic, but apparently I cashed in my cynic chips for awhile. They’re baaaaaack.

    • On The Edge

      I gotta admit, TI love ya but I wish you’d give Bonnie Raitt a break. Basing opinion of her entire career on one adult contemporary hit is like, well, hearing “Time of My Life” and presuming ALL of David Cook’s music is exactly like that. I personally know Bonnie’s old manager from the 70s-early 80s and she is a blues musician first and foremost.

      • http://topidolblog.com TopIdol

        Jesus christ. I never said I hated Bonnie Raitt and now I’m being asked to give her a break? I haven’t brought her up in weeks.

        I think Raitt is an incredible musician and a great blues artist. It was her grammy-winning foray into the AC Pop realm which I detest. Not just I Can’t Make You Love Me, but also Something to Talk About.

        I hope this clarifies things. I just hate her cookie cutter pop crap. As a blues artist, she’s fantastic.

        • Blue Eyes

          Have you listened to Bonnie’s Nick of Time cd? That cd is fantastic! I still play it to this day.

        • On The Edge

          Sorry! I apologize profusely…

  • On The Edge

    FINALLY. Read it, loved it, off to bed!

    • cc

      Yep. Worth the wait. And a proper closure to Goatboy’s Idol journey. *cheers*

  • ophelia64

    Thanks for this recap TI. I stopped watching this year after Katelyn and Lily left us, so your blog really is my only “view” of the show. Love, love your perspective and snark. I’m sure that what I’m reading is way better than what I would be seeing if I had kept watching.

    Oh, but I will be watching next week (with my finger on fast forward for a good portion of the show) to see that one guy.

    • http://topidolblog.com TopIdol

      Thank you :) I like to think I take one for the team by watching, and am just thrilled anyone ever reads them.

      (Are you in Edwardsville, btw? I’m from STL)

      • ophelia64

        Yep, I’m a prof @Southern Illinois University. fun times. I spend my days listening to students who talk like Alex Lambert and write even worse than he talks, as they tell me thinks like they took it for granite that the first paper was a rough raft, so they didn’t have to worry about me “giving” them a grade, cause your such a nice teacher and so good at learning us new things. No I’m going to have to tell my dad and he will be prostate over the whole grade situation, like, you know.

        • deez

          LOLOLOL…sounds like some Glamberts are taking your class!

        • kimberly

          “…took it for granite…” First big laugh of the morning!

          Great recap, T.I! Thinking back to Season 7, the evolution of David Cook was pretty amazing from bad fashion to the hair situation and to the weight issue. TOP 24, he was husky, had bad hair, and wore an ugly tie, but the voice could not be denied. By Top 9, his transformation from overweight, bad hair dude with a hint of arrogance to a thinner, better-dressed, not half bad-looking guy, was well underway. What was it called: the haircut felt around the world? People like being witness that type of metamorphosis. They become invested.

          Lee was a schlump in the beginning and to this day remains a schlump. There was huge transformation, not even personality-wise. Sure, he talks more, but I don’t see that as a good thing. He really doesn’t appear to have made any effort to change. After reading that Lee has made 2 CDs and is allowed to keep them up for sale,seems a bit of a slap in the face to David Cook and Adam Lambert — could have avoided the whole brouhaha about Adam not being forthright about his musical connections/past. Lessons learned for 19, I suppose. The suspicious part of me wonders if Lee DeWyze has been a ringer all along. How can someone go from perpetually singing off-key to finally hitting the notes? And doing so at just the right time. I was waiting for the big reveal and we’re getting it full-throttle. Well-played, the powers, well-played! Lee DeWyze as ringer. Crystal didn’t want to play the IDOL game, but she has will not go home empty-handed. Crystal “no health care” Bowersox has finally gotten the medical care needed for her diabetes. A far different role, I’m certain, the producers thought they would be playing with one of their contestants. Health should be her number one priority, along with her baby, for her. Runner-up or winner, it’s cool with her and she’s not being cavalier or smug when she’s saying it. It’s the truth.

          Crystal has an ease about her, a purity to her vocals, very smooth, very real. I felt the same way about Kris Allen’s vocals and style.
          Lee DeWyze is good. He can out-power Crystal vocally, but as Crystal said, “bigger is not always better.” And though it might not have helped her cause, I did love when she spoke honestly about American Idol and the OTT belting.

          Funny, I didn’t think I cared either way who won, but I guess, I do care a little. After writing all this, Dammit!, I want Crystal to win. Idol needs Crystal more than it needs another Nickelback, Hinder, dime-a-dozen singer. Lee is good, but Crystal is better.

          • kimberly

            corrections: There was no huge transformation …
            Crystal didn’t want to play the IDOL game, but she will not go home …

          • JaneRochester

            Re: Lee’s albums…they were put out by a label, not by him personally as was the case with Cook (don’t know anything about TGA). He has no say over whether those albums are available for sale right now.

          • kimberly

            To JaneRochester — so then Lee DeWyze found himself in the same situation as Adam Lambert. Adam was said to not be recieving any monies from the Take One Cd. I wonder if that holds true for DeWyze.

            Both Kris Allen and David Cook had self-produced CDs. I think they allowed the music to be downloaded free. Somehow I thought Cook was told to pull his CD. I thought it was on Amazon for awhile. Some of the details have escaped me.

            It still perplexes me how Lee had difficulty staying on key through out most of his 2 minute performances, but managed to produce two CDs. The only youtube I saw of Lee DeWyze was of him singing Simple Man in a bar sans guitar and looking a little wasted. He’s got to have had some performance experience in front of people. Just seems weird to me. But then again, tons of artists suck on live performances.

            Off topic: Adam Lambert loves all things campy per twitter. Go figure. I’d say he’s also “big” on erections. It’s like a freakin’ magic trick.

  • mozart4898

    (Don’t worry, after last night’s italics debacle, I’m done with HTML…)

    Now now, Kara couldn’t slip Casey her private number – remember, no fraternizing between the judges and contestants during and for 6 months after the show…lol. Yeah.

    I just still can’t believe they used Holy Toledo on Crystal’s video – and not just a couple seconds of it, but like practically the whole song. And at that, they did what was a really interesting edit by going from her recorded version to the bridge as she performed it live, then heading into the last chorus – she can twist her own songs live and perform them differently and give them all that much more emotion, and yet still maintain the same level of performance all the time. (And they used The Boxer for part of the background of Lee’s video…the original version, not him, because he sucks.) Truly amazing. Speaking of which – for those who stay away from MJ’s (I post there quite a bit really, I haven’t let the S8 fanwars get to me too much other than getting put in moderation for a couple comments the other night, still not sure why…) – Crystal performing another one of her originals…but, at age 13. You have GOT to hear this – http://mjsbigblog.com/crystal-bowersox-sings-at-age-13-video.htm

    I’m not going to be too ok with Lee winning. I would probably have been, except he’s coming across more and more as a smug mother-f’er, and seriously, dude cannot stay in tune to save his life. I don’t care how well he records, if he’s going to either be out of tune constantly live or autotuned – just no. Total crock of shit. And now Slumberland has popped up on the Billboard Heatseekers list too – which should encourage people to NOT vote for him since HE’S ALREADY RELEASED ALBUMS WITH A CONTRACT AND THEY HADN’T GONE ANYWHERE UNTIL HE WAS ON THE SHOW, because he SUCKS. Meh. Crystal at age 13 was better than anyone else this season – it’s not her fault that she would have probably almost been a contender at that age, in any season, and just hasn’t had much further to grow from there since.

  • Nich

    Yay I was waiting for this.

    Randy talks about how the contestants have grown because of Idol and their guidance. Casey James just starts laughing

    I loved this moment. First off Randy only names Lee and Crystal as he talks about them growing, he never says Casey’s name. I think that had to be part of the reason why Casey was all screw this, you guys suck.

    Perez fucking Hilton thinks Travis Garland — who covered T.I. (not me) and Justin Timberlake in his bedroom and filmed it one day — is EVEN BETTER THAN JUSTIN TIMBERLAKE.

    Perez Hilton is such a waste of space and a total fake. I cannot stand Justin Timberlake but even I wanted to smack Perez for that.

    • http://topidolblog.com TopIdol

      Justin Timberlake, no matter what you think of him, is undeniably talented. In a way its like saying Rockwell was better than Michael Jackson.

      • mozart4898

        Huh…I’m gonna have to try to see it in Timberlake then, because to me, he always came across as a decent singer (not OMG, just decent) who got so full of himself his ego got much much bigger than his talent. Then, if I remember right, he went hip hop or some shit and I totally just started ignoring him completely.

        • http://topidolblog.com TopIdol

          He hasn’t done much lately. I think he’s playing golf or Halo or producing stuff, who knows.

          • et

            Aw, mozart4898, you don’t like his guesty vocals on “Carryout”? Heh. He spends too much time with Timbaland.

            Actually, I always hated Timberlake because my sister was a huge huge N’SYNC fan and she worshiped him therefore since I am contrary… I hated him. But I watched some live performance and he plays the piano, the guitar, whatever and has a pretty awesome voice, too. So while I can’t say I’m a *fan* — new respect for the dude.

        • pootle

          I’m not rabid for the JT or anything, but for me he’s a charming sort of guy, has a wicked falsetto and – this is underrated – can really dance :D

    • wino

      Regardless if you like him or not, JT is a real triple threat (dance, music, acting). His Dick in a Box will forever remain my heart. Perez comparing that random douche to him is laughable.

  • margie

    That Travis dude was awful! What band was NTL exactly, because the only one I remember is O-Town.

    The actual show was blah. AI got there dream script to happen this year. woohoo!!

    • Nich

      I don’t think that NTL group ever did anything, like ever.

    • http://topidolblog.com TopIdol

      I don’t know what NTL is, but Our Beloved Frances Patron Saint of Hollywood is well-versed. Guess the kid in the wheelchair on Glee was a member.

      • erinnthered

        lol. I saw NTL, and thought “isn’t that the boyband the guy from Glee was in?” before I even finished the sentence. That’s the only reason I know they existed.

        Speaking of boy bands, did I mention that one of my bffs recorded and worked with one of the best known boy band creators in Florida? Not the creepy pedo one, the other one. I found out some very interesting things…

        Also, Taylor had one of his originals played during his hometown visit, but I doubt it was played as prominently as Crystal’s. Her song is much better.

        • Dickory Dock

          I have to ask. What very interesting things did you find out? Enquiring minds and all…

          • Verbally Dyslexic

            I want to know too!

            /nosey parker