... ...

Shock me like an (excruciatingly long) hurricane: AI9 Top 9 Results Show Recap

2010 April 7

The last thing I want to do right now is watch tonight’s American Idol results show. It may be the longest hour of the week. And look at the filler tonight! David Archuleta…Rhianna…Jason Derulo. Seriously. Try to play Marry Screw Kill with that threesome.

Tonight, Ryan promises SHOCKING results. Shock me, Ryan. Shock me. Ryan won’t shut up about the shocking results. This is probably complete bullshit, much like Kara DioGuardi’s Flying Spaghetti Monster-awful look tonight. To quote my mother when faced with such abject horror — I wouldn’t wear that to a dog fight. Why on earth is she wearing Padme Amidala’s hand-me-downs?


Extreme Idol Gives Back pimping has begun. The judges and Seacrest are all donating shit that’s taking up room in their rich people’s closets.

GROUP SING HORROR

Leading with Lee…then Big Mike…then Aaron…followed by Timmeh Cheekbones who they have hanging from the shoddy balcony. Danger! Danger! What if he falls?

Then Andrew Garcia and Casey James. Then the girls emerge from nowhere, all wearing black & white mod attire. They are led by Smug Teen Witch Katie Stevens. Jodie Foster did the whole teenage whore thing much better in Taxi Driver. Smug Teen Witch is loathesome. She also learned her stage technique from watching Sarah Palin speeches, winking like she’s in fraking Wasilla.

Bowersox is adorable walking awkwardly as she lip syncs her part in this atrocious Beatles medley. But this, not this is the scene for the ages. The next time I am sad, I will pick myself up again by staring at this lovely image.

(BTW. Siobhan. Over her. Totally over her.)

Half of the Beatles are dead. I wouldn’t be surprised if the other half offed themselves after watching this shit. I so hope Paul and Ringo are sleeping right now. They don’t need to see this fuckery. Hell, neither does Yoko Ono.

After that shit, we’re still forced to watch a lame Ford commercial about singing a song with no melody. Oh, how apropos! There is also a kaleidoscope. Smut Teen Witch is dressed like a pregnant 15-year-old.

Let’s activate the results? WTF do we need to activate? Are the Wonder Twins somewhere under a cloak of invisibility?

Seacrest starts with Siobhan. She is forced to go to the center of the stage, but no word if she is in the Bottom 3. It is also important to note she is wearing white jeans with Buddha on the thigh.

Crystal then joins Siobhan in the middle of the stage. Then its Smug Teen Witch’s turn to stand. Once again, she is wearing all of the clothes her mommy left in the bag for Goodwill. She is also wearing a t-shirt featuring all the lyrics to Let It Be. I am waiting for her pleather blazer to burst open to reveal more of this lame ass t-shirt, which might even be more groan-inducing than when David Cook Sharpied Give Back on his hand during Season 7′s Idol Gives Back. Seacrest asks her why she connected to the song. Smug Teen Witch says its was dedicated to her senile grandmother.

Seacrest asks Randy if he thinks any of these girls could be going home tonight. He says NO WAY, THESE GIRLS ARE HOT. See, they’re still trying to make everyone believe its a girl’s year. And Randy continues to skip his vocabulary building lessons on a daily basis. I have an brilliant idea! On the next results show, to make things a bit more interesting, Seacrest should administer the SAT vocab section to Randy during the first half of the show and then release the score at the end of the hour.

Sadly, if any of them were to be sent home, they would be saved. Crystal is safe. Duh. Then both the girls are sent back to the sofas. Boooooo! Smug Teen Witch and Siobhan could both go home and I would be happy. Wait. I did want to see Siobhan screech her way into trainwreck territory after she hangs out with Adam Lambert next week.

That was the most drawn out bullshit EVER. To think, we still have to endure Archuleta, Rhianna and that Jason Derulo asshat before anything fraking happens on this shit show.

When we return from the commercial break, Seacrest is sitting next to the (safe!) girls on the top row. Siobhan and Bowersox are both sitting as far away from Smug Teen Witch as humanly possible. When Seacrest announces Adam Lambert is next week’s mentor, Smug Teen Witch acts all excited. Siobhan smiles in such a forced, other-worldly WTF way, WTF am I doing here, I almost want to like her again. Bowersox can hardly hide her disappointment at having Adam Lambert mentor her AND being forced to live under the same roof as Smug Teen Witch for at least one more week.

Jason Derulo. He was signed by Shit-For-Brains. This explains everything. This guy isn’t even a one hit wonder. He’s a one hit I wouldn’t wipe my ass with this shit at a Porta-Potty at Burning Man at 2am when the toilet paper is all gone. Granted, this In My Head song is better than the Imogen Heap/The O.C. OMG SHE SHOT HIM song he ripped off. He is also wearing spikes on his shoulder. How much do you want to bet Adam Lambert’s herd of psychotic sparkle cows are already attributing Derulo’s fashion choices to their lord & savior? Hmmm…I would rather point out how he ganked all of Michael Jackson’s dance moves without even putting his own spin or finesse on them.

Derulo’s performance features stop-action camera work in black & white. Its a little disconcerting on the Idol stage. I guess last week’s seizure-inducing Dirty Diddy Money-ness was not enough for the Idol producers, who clearly hate epileptics. Derulo gets some props, though, he gives a fairly high energy performance. I think he lip synced. Seacrest allows Shit-For-Brains to talk. All you need to know is that she takes credit for all of it.

Yawn. I’m going to get a snack. You want anything?

Nope. No Bottom 3 just yet. Here is David Archuleta sitting at the baby grand, partying like its March 2008. Archie seems like a sweet kid, he really does. I have nothing against the guy. I feel bad he got stuck with shit parents and was forced to go on Star Search. He sometimes shows a predilection towards dry wit when giving interviews.

But essentially, I hate his music. Sorry, Archie. You just ain’t my style. Fast forwarding…Seacrest may as well have tea with the kid because he’s doing nothing to speed this shit show up. Amazingly, there is no commercial break!

Lee DeWyze is asked to stand up first. Seacrest asks him something. He babbles on about confidence, talks in circles. Randy calls him baby and tells him to own it. Seacrest sends him to the far side of the stage. Really. This does not make things interesting.

Michael Lynche is next. I really just want to see him next to Michael Clarke Duncan. Lynche is asked to go to the other side of the stage. Casey James is next. He is sent to stand with Lee. Oh interesting. If that’s how it goes down. Lee looks like he’s gonna puke, as per usual.

Tweenage Edward Norton Puppydog Aaron Kelly is next. I just can’t hate on this kid. I’m going soft. I know, I know. Aaron is told to stand next to Big Mike.

Then its Timmeh’s turn! Timmeh! Timmy! HE IS ASKED TO JOIN LEE AND CASEY! Is this supposed to be super obvious? Andrew is last. He will obviously be sent to stand with Aaron and Big Mike. It’s simple match.

Uh, yeah. Bottom 3 is obvious. But you know what this means?? TIMMEH IS SAFE! TIMMEH IS SAFE! My 50 votes mattered! Seacrest asks Ellen which group she thinks it is, this is never a good idea, because Ellen does not like to send anyone home.

Something dawned upon me a moment ago. I will not be content unless I see Lee DeWyze puke on stage. No, I’m not some sicko fetishist. I just want to see the dude puke. It would be more amusing than watching the other poor saps vomit, mainly because they don’t look nauseous all the time.

Whoa. Aaron Kelly is sent to safety. Dude. Are children actually voting this year? Big Mike vs. El Vez Garcia! If El Vez goes home, maybe Lee will puke.

Fast forwarding through Rhianna. Am I the only one who is completely over her voice? I think it is more important to note here that the competition’s last remaining minority contestants received the least amount of votes this week. IDOL IS RACIST!

Pre-taped Rhianna saunters down the stairs in head-to-tow black latex. Yawn. Rhianna so needs to stop ripping off Adam Lambert!

(Note to both Rhianna, Adam Lambert, Lady Gaga every other day of the week, that grimy Ke$ha chick, wait, she doesn’t count — anyway, Grace Jones did it better and always will.)

In case you were wondering, that is NOT Crystal Bowersox wielding a DeWalt sander.

After Rhianna keeps trying to brainwash us into believe she’s a Rockstar (she can pretend to play an electric guitar really well).

Finally…WTF? Dude. I kind of thought this is how it might go down. Andrew Garcia is safe.

Oh man. I feel sorry for Big Mike now. This show often plays on my heartstrings. Jesus christ. They show his sobbing wife…repeatedly. They show Bowersox sobbing…repeatedly.

Big Mike smartly sings This Woman’s Work. This actually could throw a wrench in the judges’ carefully crafted plans. They may have to pull out the bullshit save now. Will they do it? Will they do it if it means they can’t save their precious Siobhan or Smug Teen Witch?

Randy is shaking his head. Dumbfuck. Kara DioGuardi is playing all dramatic and confused. Of course, the judges were all actually listening this time around, so…

All is well! Big Mike is…SAVED. Homeboy lives to survive another week (well, actually two b/c no one is ever cruel enough to send them out the next week). And this means, two contestants will go home next week. More importantly, it means the judges can save no one else.

So when Smug Teen Witch is sent packing, no one can do a damned thing about it.

Wow. Think about how much better this episode could have been had they just done this all within the first 15 minutes.

Are you happy with the judges using their save on nice guy Michael Lynche? Who do you think will be the two contestants sent home next week? Or do you think they will send everyone home and declare Adam Lambert the champion of Season 9?

In honor of tonight’s judge’s save, let’s watch another memorable save of sorts.

Spread the word. Do it.
[Facebook] [Google] [Reddit] [StumbleUpon] [Twitter] [Yahoo!] [Email]
  • nicolle

    I just read your recap for the first time, and I have to say that I love it! I usually only read VFTW, but you’ve totally won me over.

  • dfeeel2

    Sadz top idol.

    I love siobhan.
    I dont appreciate the hate.

    The whole quirky thing isnt a shtick.
    Shes genuinely just freakin awesome.

    • http://topidolblog.com TopIdol

      Sometimes I dig Siobhan. Sometimes, I really do. Then other times, she lets me down.

      I love her quirkiness. I really do. I just think she may have already peeked on the show. Still love her Wicked Game, but her Chaka Kahn was a hot mess. Can’t say I don’t blame the judges for their sometimes baffling advice, though.

      • dfeeel2

        Yeah i feel you, no worries.
        But she was good Tuesday and she’s someone who I would love to just sit down and talk to….
        (Ah the giddy delights of being Michael Slezak)

  • http://princessleia04.livejournal.com SarahBeth

    You know what’s really apparent/interesting to me after last night? How much the contestants really do not like each other.

    Seriously.

    Remember last year, when Matty G (AND QUATTO) were saved? He got like, tacklehugged to the ground. This year? There was some polite clapping from the other one. Its sad how cold this group is – they don’t seem close at all.

  • Kathy

    Timmy wasn’t even in the bottom 3. I giggled like a school girl.

  • Sandy

    Yay for Timmeh!! Woot! Woot! I was so happy for him that he wasn’t even in the Bottom 3. He seems like the only contestant that is even happy to be there and enjoying his time on the show. Good for him!

  • kimberly

    One problem I think with TUrban is he’s starting to beleive the judges are now taking him seriously as a viable contestant and he’s falling for it. (The smackdown won’t be pretty. I hope they don’t shatter him completely.) The magic of Tim was when the judges were being dicks and Tim used it to his advantage, didn’t let them break him. He relished it, worked with it. Maybe that’s where Lee’s bagpipe came into play — working the whole so bad, it’s good. TPTB stealing Tim’s shtick, not realizing the “Tim Win” is a big FU to them or realizing it and trying to work it to their advantage. Power struggle FTW!

    Siobhan is not as appealing to me anymore, either. Crystal is very,very good, but I’m not blown away by her. This group is not endearing themselves to me. They are all so weirdly dysfunctional, which I usually like. But something just isn’t working for me. Nothing special going on with Lee, Casey or Andrew.

    Last year, Kris Allen was openly affectionate, a huge hugger. I think he rubbed off on the rest of the contestants. (I’m not just saying this because I’m a fan of Kris. Interesting to note, Danny and Scott weren’t on the recieving end of Kris’ hugs all that much.) The guys were all very, very huggy after awhile. I don’t think any group/season displayed as much affection as last year. I didn’t realize how “happy” it made me to watch people openly show their love for each other. I’m a sap.

    Oh, and the “wouldn’t wear that to a dogfight”, my mom used to say the same thing. Laughed out loud when I read it. She had a million of those gems. I like using them once in awhile on people because I think they’re so funny.

    • kimberly

      once and awhile. fail!

    • ftube2009

      “Interesting to note, Danny and Scott weren’t on the receiving end of Kris’ hugs all that much.”

      We saw Gokey grope Allison’s chest during that staged “food fight”. Kris probably steered clear to avoid a similar fate.

  • Dickory Dock

    Big Mike in a vest is not a good look. It makes him resemble a child’s drawing; the kind where there is no discernible neck/shoulder/elbow definition, but rather a sort of Michelin Man effect.

    I just read the behind the scenes recap at EW, and these quotes make me for real laugh:

    “As far as I can tell, Lee looks like he’s having his toenails ripped out at all times.”

    and

    “Lee went to the far side, where he looked ever so slightly less waterboarded than usual”

    Heh.

    God, this season is boring.

  • et

    As is the usual for Wednesdays, I watched this crapfest and texted back and forth with my sister. We’ve both been watching since Season 1 (her) and Season 2 (me) and we finally had to confess that this is the worst season ever and boring as shit. Heh. She about blew a gasket when she realized Big Mike was going to be in the Bottom 3, little sis loves him and was going on Idol-strike if he left. I didn’t want him to go either because at least he’s sorta entertaining in his big lumbering way. Plus he’s nice. Plus there are a bunch that should go before he does and that messes up my top 4 of Crystal…… then Lee/Casey/Mike. So no can do. And I HATE when this show messes with my emotions and I felt really bad for Mike/sobbing wife/whatever. Doesn’t this group of Idols just look… drained? They are always so sad/terrified/nervous/whatever. Spark of life, kids! Show a spark of life! I think that’s why I am liking TIMMEH. At least he’s enjoying himself.

    I went and walked the dog during Rihanna. She got the Katie treatment. Derulo was ok, and Archie is adorable but I would have been ok without him singing Imagine again.

    So, next week we get Glambert. Oh, yay!

    • Sandy

      Poor Archie! Not only did he not get to sing one of his own songs, he didn’t even get to do anything new. It was like he was stuck in a time warp.

  • girl from mars

    Thank you for watching this so I didn’t have to. I watched an X-Files episode about giant killer roaches who are able to trick people into thinking they’re human, and then they make humans into zombies. Wait, maybe I did watch this episode.

  • Pandora

    I don’t even think Derulo’s songs are that bad, so I was going to check out his performance, but as soon as he name-checked himself, ZAP went the fastforward button. Anyone who name-checks themself is automatically on my shit list forever more.

    And, please, why doesn’t Rihanna just release the same fricking song over and over again? Oh wait, she does, doesn’t she, just changes the title. She’s another one I just don’t get. Of all her crap songs there’s only been one I could even stand to listen to.

    Yay for Timmy, and if TBTB don’t watch out and start calling Lee out on the fact that he sings off key most of the time he’s going to end up winning the stupid show.

  • http://www.detailsinthefabric.tk/ Shosh

    I love David Archuleta’s voice. His next album had better not have machines in it or I will cut someone. In half.
    I say this b/c this is the only part of the results show I bothered watching. Obviously. David Archuleta being on American Idol brings the tard out of me. It’s embarrassing as hell.
    Also, THANK GOD THEY USED THE SAVE ON BIG MIKE. I AM SO HAPPY.
    Also, I am so, so very ashamed that you voted for Tim 50 FRAKING TIMES. You’re not supposed to vote! You’re a blogger who doesn’t give a shit! D:

    • http://topidolblog.com TopIdol

      That’s what’s so sad, you know? Is that I don’t care, yet felt compelled to vote for Timmeh 50 times b/c that’s how much the show sucks.

      But we all know why I did it. Last week, he talked back to Kara. Homeboy EARNED his votes from me.

  • michelle

    Popping in for a minute before going to bed. I was going to reply in the thread about Adam-you know the one with over six hundred posts but Idoltard was giving me an AO flashback and it scared me. Ha, not really, just tired of trying to reason with people like that.

    Anyway, I’m glad they used the save on Mike. He’s the only guy on the show I would want to listen to and he seems like a nice guy. This season really sucks.

    • jennwin

      Yes. Yes it does.

  • Kate123

    I missed tonight’s episode…did they say what next week’s theme is? I really would not have guessed Big Mike would be the one with the lowest amount of votes but w.e I’m glad they saved him. He seems like a nice guy and now they can’t use the save on certain other contestants.

    I am probably in the minority here on this but I kind of like this season because everyone seems pretty raw and inexperienced and when watching these kind of shows I hare seeing professionals. I always kind of thought of this show as for the people that really wouldn’t be able to otherwise pursue a musical career due to family issues, relative poverty, location, etc… Not the people that move to LA out of highschool and relentlessly go after a career in the biz. Reality TV in general just seems so calculating and scripted…it’s nice to have contestants that aren’t…even if they’re kind of…lacklustre

    • http://topidolblog.com TopIdol

      Speaking of relative poverty, what happened to Orphan Boy?

      BTW, Welcome Kate! I’m glad you’re commenting now! More lurkers should come out and play.

      • Kate123

        I think he was disqualified and Tim urban took his spot (lol)

        And thanks for the welcome :D

    • 8sourcandy

      “Reality TV in general just seems so calculating and scripted…it’s nice to have contestants that aren’t…even if they’re kind of…lacklustre”

      Unfortunately, “lackluster” isn’t a music genre.

  • nerdgirl

    What I couldn’t understand, why Kara was hugging Simon after he announced that Mike was saved. Didn’t she participate in decision-making process? It looked weird.

    And TI, I started following you on Twitter, I hope you don’t mind.

    • http://topidolblog.com TopIdol

      I would love more non-spam followers on Twitter. :)

  • Nich

    I’m over Big Mike. Actually I was never into him to begin with. I was hoping they wouldn’t use the save but when he started singing you knew they would. The rest of the Top 9 seemed like they were faking their happiness cause you know Big Mike isn’t going anywhere next week when he really should be.

    • http://topidolblog.com TopIdol

      The beauty about saving Big Mike is that they can’t use it on Smug Teen Witch or Siobhan now.

      • deez

        It would be so awesome if Siobhan AND Bristol Palin both went home next week.

        • melbelle

          it’s going to be hard for the stw to survive a double elimination, especially if the theme is a more current one – hence adam as mentor. but maybe the theme is classic rock? haha

          considering everyone’s dream of sending stw home in time for prom, the timing of this save is impeccable. and tim’s safe!! alright alright

        • Mary

          Deez, your horrible. I laughed out loud in class right now when I read your Bristol Palin comment, and now I’m embarassed. She does remind me of her!

  • On The Edge

    Wonderful…someone I know IN REAL LIFE, somebody I work with, has called me out, on Twitter no less. Wondering why I voted for Timmy, wondering “why do you watch the show if you don’t even like it?” Oh great, she’s one of THOSE people. I like her, she’s an awesome creative person and is really into theater and musicals and stuff, so she loves Idol and Glee and all of that. But she takes it too seriously. Yes, I get it, someone who was good almost went home…but it’s TEEVEE, and it’s not the end of Mike’s career, jeez.

    You know, now that I think about it her favorites last year were Adam and Danny…

    • On The Edge

      And I gotta confess, I actually like Tim now. Sure I started voting for him because he was the “worst” pick, but shucks that tousled hair and mega-watt earnest smile and infectious positive “I’m just so lucky to be here!” attitude won me over!

      Probably won’t buy his records, but no one’s perfect.

      • jennwin

        I was called out on Facebook for voting for Timmeh. I voted like, 7 times for him, which is a record for me. Is he the most talented? No. But he genuinely seems happy to be there. This season is just BLAH. Last season EVERYONE seemed happy to be there (including Kareoke Gokey), and they seemed to really enjoy each other’s company. Last season, I was a lurker here, but all of the pet names TI gave to the contestants still stick with me (Hot By Default, Casper, El Princesa, Pastor Rolex!, etc.). I remember individual performances (Falling Slowly, Mad World, Hot Stuff, hell even Endless Love).

        That’s why I’m voting for Tim. Last season, he would have totally been gone by now, but this season, he is truly the only person to exhibit JOY when he is on the stage. Crystal is awesome, but she’s too good for this shit show, and she knows it. And that is not a bad thing. Timmeh knows he is lucky to be where he is, and gosh darn’t, he is going to ENJOY himself.

        Last season had suspense. Last season, I was rooting for everyone, except Casper and Gokey, and on occasion, Not So ‘Lil Rounds. Because each contestant (exceptions above) had personality and was LIKEABLE.

        I know I shouldn’t compare this year’s crapfest to last, but what can I do? At least Tim is there 3-5 minutes a week to remind me that AI can be fun to watch every now and again.

        • jennwin

          Oh, I should also mention I’m kind of a Kristard. I submitted five votes for him last year, and it was exhilarating.

          • saskin

            I would recommend not letting people discourage you. You can tell them that winning the show really doesn’t mean anything at all since TPTB will go ahead and treat their chosen one as the real winner like they did with Lambert.

      • BettyBlue

        I, too, started rooting for Timmeh(!) because he was entertainingly bad. Now I kinda like him. His megawatt smile is so infectious.

        • Blue Eyes

          I love Timmy!

  • jennwin

    HAHAHA!

    Apparently, while I was holding my breath waiting to see if my precious Timmeh was safe, I killed a few brain cells in the process (Seacrest was totally dragging that shit out tonight, worse than usual, no?). So, I’m totally light headed and slightly tipsy and then this THING comes sauntering down the stairs in a shiny vinyl catsuit, and I was like, WTF is Glambert doing here tonight? Slightly confusing, as I thought he was the mentor on NEXT week’s show?!? I was looking at him and was thinking, wow! He’s looking good, definitely lot less pasty then usual! And then I realized it was Rhianna. So either they share a costume designer, or one of them have been dumpster diving at the other’s house.

    Glad to see we were on the same page there.

    And yay!!! Timmeh lives to see another day!

    • http://topidolblog.com TopIdol

      No, Jenn. Adam Lambert has made everyone want to dress like him. Oh. And here is what some of the sparkle herd is speculating about for next week’s “very special theme.”

      Or maybe they can do songs adam has sang, that would be great. I am wondering if all 9 contestants are going to see adam in Vancouver tommrow! Ahhadam maybe onto somthing! I betya!

      • jennwin

        Oh gawd, I’m getting scared. Although, I would love to see Timmeh attempt Glamberace’s version of Ring of Fire. That would be AMAZING.

        • Pandora

          Let’s get our stories straight. It wasn’t even Glamberace’s version. He completely stole it from someone else, so it was his karaoke version of someone else’s version.

          • http://topidolblog.com TopIdol

            Is everyone okay with me using Glamberace for now on? I’ve wanted to for awhile, but feel like I would be stealing from Michael K. (Dlisted), yet its my favorite Adam Lambert moniker.

          • Mithra

            He stole it from another reality TV show contestant. Dilana from Rockstar Supernova. I believe there are other similar versions out there too, also predating the RAWK GAWD.

      • jukejoint

        Adam has sang? I despair of the Glambert Nation ever learning the proper past participle of “sing.” Sing, sang, sung, people. He sings today, he sang yesterday, he has SUNG in the past… HAS SUNG. SUNG.

        Don’t mind me. Certain things just get under my skin. Like STW, D’Arch Vader, “had went” and “had sang.”

        I think the theme should be “songs from crappy musicals.” Wicked, that other Biblical thing Lamebert was in, anything with music by Frank Wildhorn…

        • http://topidolblog.com TopIdol

          It’s tardspeak. The Confrau all say shit like Greekboy can sang!!!

          Confrauen were my first exposure to Idol fantards. I knew Claymates existed and that my good friend went on a Claymate booze cruise with her mother (it was a Clay Concert Eve Celebration), but I had no idea anyone else attracted crazy intense fans. Especially that bastard.

          • deez

            Didn’t that Christian singer that Gokey hooked up wi…err… met, tweet that he “could sang?”

          • jennwin

            There were Claymate Booze Cruises? Damn, nothing brings out the Frau like “straight” gay guys.

        • deez

          I have noticed that the more deranged the Sparkle Cow, the less handy they are with the English language. (I’d like to go through Kerry’s “book” with a red pen…or several)

          • ftube2009

            “I’d like to go through Kerry’s “book” with a red pen…or several”

            I heard a rumor that a book review is in the works. Wonder if the 3rd grade grammar & spelling will be mentioned?