... ...

Oh yeah. It’s totally a girl’s year, isn’t it? AI9 Top 10 Results Show Recap

2010 March 31

Tonight’s results show begins with a truly over-the-top tie-in for Clash of the Titans. Clash of the Titans is bound to be shit, like 300 or 10,000 BC or all of the above. Pearl Cream is making me see Clash of the Titans when he comes to town next week. Ordinarily I would say, no way, dude. No way. Let’s go see Hot Tub Time Machine. But I’m gonna let him have this one, mainly because I now know who Sam Worthington is and that he might be even better to look at as a non-paraplegic and I am curious as to what his chest looks like…not blue.

Ruben Studdard is performing some throwaway R&B number. There is nothing current or relevant about his performance, as I expect it to be played on Delilah-Love-Someone-Tonight’s syndicated nightly radio show. I never watched a single episode of Ruben’s season, but I like the guy. He has also mastered the art of SMIZING. Tyra Banks has nothing on the Velvet Teddy Bear!

Is Sam Worthington in the audience? Why has Ruben Studdard become a vegetarian? Naturally, Ruben needs to stand next to heir apparent, Michael Lynche, who is…wearing a ponytail? Like a My-Little-Ponytail?

WHY THE HELL IS RUBEN STUDDARD TOURING WITH CLAY AIKEN? Wow. How the not-that-mighty have fallen.

The Claymates will be happy.

Awww, look. Ryan made a funny.

FORD COMMERCIAL TIME — EVERYBODY WAS FAUX KUNG FU FIGHTING

The Top 10 borrowed some waiters’ uniforms and went out to film a Ford Commercial. I do not believe any of these people know kung fu.

I really do not want to make a Kim Jong Illin joke right now. HE IS EVEN WEARING RED! RED! Hello propaganda poster!

Casey is the “odd man out” of tonight’s Ford ad. He wore a t-shirt and drove off in the Ford. I think the moral of the story is to not fight with one another and drive away…in a Ford.

After the commercial, we learn Siobhan Magnus was behind Michael Lynche’s mystery My-Little-Ponytail. (And in case you cared, his wife likes it.)

Ryan goes through and asks the contestants what they felt about the judges’ critiques from last night. Mama Garcia is now wearing plaid! Mama Garcia will never be Mama Yamin, but the woman is now even beating Casey James’ mama as most fashionable Idol matriarch EVER.

To continue on with tonight’s Clash of the Titans promotion, the cast of the film got drunk at the London premiere and were forced to film a greeting to the Top 10 American Idol contestants because their balls are owned by Fox for the time being. Never mind none of them are American nor would ever watch American Idol. I actually do not mind this crap tonight because a) Idol sucks ass and b) I like looking at Sam Worthington for whatever reason.

Lee DeWyze is safe. But his pants are still falling down and he still looks like he might vomit. Casey James is safe. Seacrest asks Aaron Kelly if he’s ever been in love, but uses it to involve Simon in some nonsense. Simon, in turn, tells Seacrest its not the Oprah Winfrey Show. And then they fake fight again. And then Seacrest allows Kara DioGuardi to speak and she says something lame and unoriginal about Simon being in love with himself. Even Ellen is keeping her mouth shut because this dog & pony show is so lame.

Its Siobhan vs. Smug Teen Witch! YAY! Smug Teen Witch is TOTALLY in the Bottom 2! You know something? I no longer want to hear the judges debating on what the frak kind of artist any contestant should be. This shit should be figured out before they go on the program. And the homoerotic tension-filled faux fighting between Simon and Seacrest is just so mind-numbingly lame, its like watching –

NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

Die. Bieber. Die. The Imp of Hades is finally taking some of Ryan’s candy! It seems his performance will be aired during next week’s results show, after the contestants sing selections from the Lennon-McCarthy songbook. (Because we all know how well that turned out the first time…AND the second time.) You think John Lennon wanted it this way? Huh? Is this anyway to honor the man’s memory? Justin fucking Bieber.

Usher comes out and sings his newest release. It’s better than Yeah Yeah Yeah but then again, the sounds of someone taking a shit in the stall next to you are infinitely better than Yeah Yeah Yeah. Is Usher even singing in this number? He ain’t rapping. He’s just talking. Usher is wearing a derby hat and there is choreography involving the aforementioned derby hat often seen in high school girls’ pom squads. Then that will.i.am idiot shows up.

will.i.am : pop music :: Chef Boyardee : pasta

Is it just me, or do these people all hate each other?

Didi is in the Bottom 3. As if this was a shock to anyone? Drunki is clearly about to break down. It would probably be in everybody’s best interests if she goes home tonight. We also learn she gets nervous playing guitar on stage, even though I thought she was all singer-songwriter girl. FAKE. Drunki at least, accepts her fate. She also gets points for not hugging Smug Teen Witch as she takes her seat beside her.

Seacrest’s fake out to Michael Lynche fools no one, but it does give Big Mike to bring on the feats of strength like its Festivus morning! He also may have grabbed Seacrest’s nuts, not sure.

Since we all know Crystal Bowersox is a-ok, its going to come down to Tim Urban and Andrew Garcia for that final spot in the Bottom 3. Sadly, we know this will be Tim Urban, whose incredible Idol run should not end just yet. I don’t understand why they are so perplexed as to why Tim Urban smiles all the time. The kid was HOME SCHOOLED. HOME SCHOOLED. Of course, even Tim manages to semi-charm me with his reply when Kara asks him why he smiles all the damn time. It’s a good attitude to have, and frankly, she should just shut her useless trap if she doesn’t get it. Oh yeah. Shit-for-Brains is a failed pop singer stuck writing shitty songs for other people. She’s not even allowed on stages in front of large audiences.

Of course Tim Urban smiles all the time. He was a homeschooled child of Jesus. Life is lollipops, DC Talk and a closet full of American Eagle to wear to all those church lock-ins and youth ministry night.

BOOOOOO! Smug Teen Witch is sent back to safety.

Before we get to send Drunki or Teflon Timmy on their way, we must sit through a Diddy performance. Diddy Dirty Money. The smoke machines are on full blast. And the lights go crazy. I bet $20 an epileptic has already called Fox because there was no fair warning about extreme strobe lightage for this episode.

YES YES YES! It’s a VFTW victory! Tim Urban is safe safe safe! And Drunki gets to break down on stage one final time. The judges aren’t saving her ass, even if she’s doing Stevie Nicks. Sadly, its the best she’s sounded on the show, although she’s still not very good at expressing the true emotion of a song. The judges, naturally, act like asshats and talk about shit their maid said while she’s performing.

So yeah…um, Idol? It’s still a girl’s year, right? You get it now, right? The people voting for your shit show uh, don’t usually vote for the girls and now, half the girls are gone.

Keep smiling, Teflon Timmy, keep smiling.

Spread the word. Do it.
[Facebook] [Google] [Reddit] [StumbleUpon] [Twitter] [Yahoo!] [Email]
  • Mithra

    I’m thinking that now that they are tied in, that yeah – the top 5 this year will also get a Disney bonus. I do know that season 7 people taped segments for the attraction, but I’m not sure if it was just the top 5. The opening was right before season 8 started airing. It’s interesting to see who attended the grand opening and who didn’t.

    http://mjsbigblog.com/more-photos-from-the-american-idol-experience-grand-opening.htm

    • Mithra

      Oh dammit, this was supposed to be a response to TI way down near the bottom of the comments.

  • Burgundy LaRue

    Will this year be a rehash of Season 6. . .or Season 4? Many say S6, but S4 had three girls to be bounced out at 12-11-10 and Carrie Underwood still won. Of course, none of the remaining women are nearly as strong or commercially viable as Underwood. But it’s an interesting story to watch unfold.

    • jukejoint

      I’m already on the record with my cycles of 5 thing. So I say season 4 mirrors this one, except the winner will not be Idol’s biggest sellah evah. It’ll be a white girl, though.

      • Burgundy LaRue

        Hmm, I don’t know. With Idol’s demographics beings as they are (white cougars), another WGWG (White Guy With Guitar) might win. Lee is probably too similiar to Chris Daughtry, but Casey is a bluesy-rock singer who’s one of the strongest musicians they’ve had since they allowed contestants to play instruments. Casey is the slightly younger, easier on the eyes version of Taylor Hicks. And the fraus love him.

        Yeah, Casey’s doomed.

  • Chester

    Ok, this is what I think.
    First of all english is my second language, so please, do not comment on spelling or grammar.

    I am Adam’s fan.
    Kerry Kolsch is an idiot. Kris won fair and square, there was no conspiracy. Adam is simply more polarizing, Kris is more mainstream. Both are very talented, just different.

    Adam is not a Rawk God, and is doing pretty well so far. I have no idea what will future bring, I wish him the best of luck. I bought his CD. One copy.

    Kris is doing OK, I simply think that he found himself in the position he did not expected to be. (Be careful what you wish for). As in Adam’s case I have no idea what his future will look like and I wish him the best of luck, because he is nice, cool dude. I didn’t buy his CD.

    RCA is doing good job promoting Adam, Jive seems to be dragging its feet.

    Fanwar is idiotic, I was called sparkle cow once too many times and I snapped. I hope that term “sparkle cow” should be buried forever. With some of the Worsters.

    I guess , that’s it. Aha, Happy Passover and Easter.

  • Blue Eyes

    A few thoughts on this season…

    – Timmy is saving a boring season – the same way Sanjaya saved Season 6, probably the most boring season of Idol ever. Say whatever you want, but I don’t think Timmy is all that bad. Given a teen song that Justin Beiber would sing, that kid could be a huge star. Will anyone deny he’s one handsome kid? That’s about all it takes these days to make it in music.

    – I think the final three will be Crystal, Lee and Casey. I have a feeling Lee will win and Crystal will come in second.

    • dresden

      he’s 20 years old. not a kid, and too old to be playing to that beiber demographic. granted, he is entertaining in a wtf kinda way, but i just find myself getting as bored with him as everyone else this season. everything about this season feels recycled, done before but better, vanilla, tired. i saw where rating dipped for the results show into the teens – 1st time in a while idol has not had 20+ mil watching. the country is steadily beginning to tune this mess out, and there’s no denying it once it starts showing up in the ratings. if another wgwg wins, i tell you, it’s over.

      • Blue Eyes

        I didn’t know he was 20. Thought he was 17 or 18. Sorry.

        Goes to show you how much I’m paying attention to this season.

  • Pingback: American Idol – American Idol News » American Idol 9 Top 10 Results – Recap Roundup

  • kimberly

    This season is America’s revenge for giving us Glamberts.

    • Kathy

      bawahaha

  • kimberly

    BOLD PREDICTION: TOP 2 FINALISTS — Katie Stevens (STW) and Andrew Garcia (El Vez)(Kim Jong) BWAH HA HA!!!!

    I think Andrew Garcia had a following before coming to IDOL and it increased after the Hollywood week hype. Gang Power! Once Katie Stevens goes country, there’ll be no stopping her. Maria Osmond Jr. — I’m a little bit country …

    I can see it all now.

    • jukejoint

      I think Crystal will win, Lee or Casey will place, and Katie will show. Aaron may make it as high as four. A boy will go next week. But don’t be surprised if it’s another girl after that.

      I still think a girl will win, though. It’s just a weird bunch from top to bottom, with none of the usual Idol types. Plus they seem to have pimped all the wrong people in the early going. Last year, you could tell from auditions and Hollywood week they wanted Danny, Adam, Matt and Lil. This year, it seemed like Andrew, Michael Lynche and Katie were the big pimpees. The only other girl I can remember seeing anything of was Katelyn, and she was at the very beginning of auditions with not much Hollywood week. I don’t remember what they showed of Haeley or Siobhan. I do recall that they threw Crystal and Didi into that last “best of the rest” show. So who the heck were they thinking of with all this Year of the Girl stuff? Crystal and Lilly were sooooo not the AI type.

      Are they completely rethinking the Pimp Model? Did they really want Michael, Andrew and Katie to be their top 3 seeds?

      I think maybe 1) they’re as confused as we are, 2) they are throwing in the towel and going for a free-for-all season since Simon is leaving after this, or 3) they really screwed up.

      • http://topidolblog.com TopIdol

        I’m thinking next week, they will boot Tim Urban no matter how many votes he has. Because Tim Urban is now unstoppable in a Sanjaya sense.

        • Mary

          NOOOOO not my timmehhhh!!! i love that guy, and I loved how he talked back to Kara, that stupid bitch.

          If they use the save, it will probably be on Garcia or STW. but I don’t think they are going to use the save at all this year. Whats the point? Quatto got booted 2 weeks later anyways.

          • Mithra

            That NYT article about last seasons contract disclosures made the “save” twist a bit more…interesting. I think that last year, because of the Disney Experience tie in, was the first year that the top 5 ALSO got a bonus $50,000 from Disney. That’s HUGE. I suspect the save may have been created for this. Matt clearly was not going to go the distance, and they did not sign him, but I don’t think they wanted Anoop or Lil to get that. Maybe?

          • http://topidolblog.com TopIdol

            Wouldn’t the Disney Experience bonus still be around this year since the attraction is still open? Or was it just a one-time thing?

        • Mithra

          When is IGB? That may be when they decide to not count certain votes, like they did with Sanjaya.

          It’s interesting that Tim is picking up the momentum in a similar “screw Idol” way. All the multiple contestants dubbed “the next Sanjaya”s never had as much of an impact of turning people to vote ALONG with VFTW before from what I’ve seen. These contestants incluse Danny Noriega (the first Sanjaya 2.0), KKKristy, Jason Castro, Normund, Tatiana, and yes…hear the sound of stampeding and mooing coming…The RAWK GAWD himself.

          The situation with Tim is that people WANT to vote for him now. Sanjaya went far as a worst pick because people WANTED to vote for him. It’s a perfect storm of multiple voting blocks. It’s not really being picked up by the media beyond the Idol community though. I’ve also read comments that Ryan is not announcing the vote totals any more. I haven’t noticed. There may be a huge drop off of interest.

          • Mithra

            How could I have forgotten Megan? :D This is an interesting thread on the scaries:

            http://myidol.americanidol.com/go/thread/view/86789/23058977/Tims_response_to_Kara_was..?pg=1&pg=1

            There is clearly a backlash against Kara. She’s pretty much not well liked as it is, but she’s crossed a line for many who didn’t really even like Tim. This alone could buy him a few weeks, or at least ONE, that is if the vote count is on the up and up. I do recall now that there were threads a couple years ago started by MODs, paid employees of 19/FOX/TPTBwhatevia – that they DO throw out suspicious looking votes and advising posters not to waste their time power voting texts thousands of times from single lines. I suspect though that they only do this when they want to. Another example of sketchy vote results is when Castro was clearly being thrown under the bus, but Pauler messed things up, which seems to have bought him another week.

      • Pandora

        Right about now I’m actually wondering what the difference is between Katie and Tim? Neither can actually connect to the lyrics of a song. Neither has any real stage presence. Neither has actually given a GOOD vocal thus far.

        Tim is prettier than Katie, though, and definitely seems to have more of a personality.

        So why are they slobbering over her again?

        • http://topidolblog.com TopIdol

          If the Flying Spaghetti Monster is smiling upon us, Katie will get the boot next week.

          And the judges will save her. Ugh. This is why there is no Flying Spaghetti Monster!

          • saskin

            Goodness. Then there will be only 2 girls in the top 8 and one of them can’t really sing so much as scream (did you guys notice Kara said ‘screaming’ instead of ‘belting’. Ha ha.).

          • Pandora

            Hmm, if we are lucky enough that Katie gets booted, I will have to find someone new to hate. Didi was pretty high on my hate-list herself.

            Hating Aaron would be like kicking a puppy. Hating Andrew is too predictable. Maybe when Katie goes I’ll start hating Lee just because he doesn’t seem to have any haters yet, plus the slobbering over him is getting annoying too.

          • jukejoint

            I hate Siobhan. Feel free to jump on that bandwagon.

          • deez

            Scooch over a tad, I think I want up there too.

  • Mithra

    I’ve been thinking about all these cries of this being THE WORST SEASON EVER. I don’t think it is. I think besides Simon’s Leonabots and STW – most are not the typical pagenty Idol type contestants. They are not OMG the next INTERNATIONAL SUPERSTAR, but neither is ADAM, or Cook, etc.

    What I suspect is that the last two seasons were so OTT fantarding heavy that many online posters and bloggers are just burnt out.

    • Kathy

      Interesting point. I think season 6 was the worst. There was not one person I rooted for in any way. I voted only for the finale and then it was a vote against Blake not for Jordan. At least this season has Crystal even if she is too good for this crap.

      • On The Edge

        I disagree, though I think Season 6 suffered from the same problem as Season 5. The best singer (Melinda Doolittle, IMHO) wasn’t a “commercial” singer. Taylor wasn’t a commercially viable artist either, but he won. I did buy Melinda’s album and LOVE it, but then I really love female blues and jazz singers like Big Mama Thornton, Koko Taylor, Memphis Minnie, Etta James, Ella Fitzgerald, etc.

        • Kathy

          The Melinda point is true. I am partial to season 5 though as 2 of my fave Idols were in that season. I like Chris (even if he is a little Nickleback) and Bucky. I can’t help it I love a southern rock/country guy. Big Bo fan as well. But I agree that as winners go, Season 5 tanked with Taylor.

    • auntieaimee

      Mithra, I totally agree.

    • Burgundy LaRue

      It wouldn’t be so bad if the curtain jerkers in charge of the show hadn’t tinkered with what already worked. The contestants aren’t the problem. Sure, there are several weak links this time around, but that’s always been the case–you get 3-4 strong candidates and the rest are basically fodder. Crystal, Lee, Mike, and Casey would make for a solid Top 4.

      But because Simon Fuller and Co. have *&^%#@ up, they want everyone to say that it’s a abnormally weak talent pool. It’s not. And even if it were, guess who picked these contestant for the Top 24? The judges and producers, you turkeys!

      The show’s getting old. There have been too many changes behind the scenes. Simon is moving on to his next cash cow. And the tards have been in a two-year tizzy. It just adds up to what we have now–a mess.

      These can be salvaged if they wanted to do so. But with declining ratings and The X-Factor coming in next year, I’m guessing 19 is just ready to move on.

  • Pandora

    I am so glad I didn’t bother to watch this. I would, however, have liked to see the judges’ faces when Tim was safe. If anybody has a link, please share.

    And next week I promise to fully embrace my inner Worster and start voting for Tim.

  • Sherena

    I can’t believe KATIE is now among the top 3 girls– who woulda thunk it? I mean really. Really.

    Also, the AI audience still hates women, etc.

  • GoatLove

    This is going to sound weird, but last night, (I hadn’t watched the train wrecks from Tuesday yet) I had a dream that I was Tim Urban and I was on American Idol. I knew that I was mostly tone deaf and that I couldn’t sing… yet AI still wanted me to compete.

    I wish I wrote down the song I “picked” in my dream but – damn, there was no way it was going to happen.

    I was locked into a contract where I had to perform. No way out or I was screwed….. I sang the easier parts mostly out of tune….. and then for the sections that definitely weren’t going to happen, I broke into Blake Lewis beat boxing. In the dream, I knew it was ridiculous, but I didn’t know what else to do.

    This was one of those nightmares that you wake up in the middle – sweating – and happily realize it’s not really happening…. and then you fall back to sleep, and it starts up again. It was some crazy shizay.

    Moral to the story is that Tim is the bomb and has it going on.

    • saskin

      I feel the same way. But I think it is because after Paula the judging table lost it’s balance. I said this before, it used to be if Simon says someone is good it means he/she is really good, if Paula can’t say he/she was good it meant he/she is really bad. They lost the heart of the judging table. She was crazy but people trusted her to say something positive. Now it is all different shades of negative.

      Like when Sio messed up; Paula could effectively communicate (I can’t believe I wrote that) why we should keep believing in her whereas Kara’s argument fell flat. I think because of this, people are finally watching the same show I’ve been watching (on and off) for years; all of the contestants are cast to play a part in this karaoke competition, they are not really singers, they all suck but the panel tries to get rid of them in a certain order which has nothing to do with singing at all.

      I think Timmeh is caught up in an unpleasant situation and he effectively communicated (OMG, not again) his dilemma so people are feeling for him.

      • Sandy

        I actually miss Paula. I would not miss Kara, Randy or even Ellen. I hope they go back to three judges because the show is way too much about the judging right now. And I hope they can get a decent replacement for Simon.

        • Sandy

          I just had an awful thought that they could go back to three judges by just not replacing Simon and leave it at Randy, Kara and Ellen. Randy is useless, Ellen is no Paula and not nearly as funny as I thought she’d be and Kara makes me want to punch her in the nose everytime she opens her mouth.

          • Burgundy LaRue

            Wipe out the entire judging panel after this year. Go back to a three-person brain trust. That would at least set some things right.

            Really, if they just got rid of Kara, I would be OK with things. I want to hurt her bad. Real bad. Michael Jackson bad.

  • cc

    OT but this got me thinking about TI’s “How hard can you tard?” contest. Gosh, it should be the best thing that will happen this season….. *sigh*

    LOL. I can’t imagine someone going to tard over Smug Teen, Andrew, Aaron….. :D

  • saskin

    Did you guys hear that Adam inspired Ricky Martin to come out? Heh. Ridiculous. But he inspired me to come out. I was a teen witch myself in high school. There I said it. It wasn’t my fault. But I kinda turned out OK. I like to believe so.

    Soooo, when I saw the picture of the teen witch above, in the recap, I kinda thought that all the people who now send me messages on facebook saying ‘do you remember me, I used to be your neighbor/classmate/teammate? that I can’t remember; that is exactly how they perceived me in high school. Crap. Whereas it was not my fault. Oy.

    • Sherena

      Ricky Martin came out?????!!!! Not that it’s terribly surprising, I just thought he’d never get around to it…

      • saskin

        Yeah. All because Adam proved that you can be gay and singer at the same time. :) I’m sure pretty soon a lot of Broadway people will get the courage to come out because of Adam too.

        • Mithra

          I don’t know if anyone posted this yet, but I found the link scanning through MJ’s just now. Krazy Kerry weighs in on season 9 :D :

          http://www.associatedcontent.com/article/2848056/adam_lambert_wont_you_please_come_home.html?cat=2

          • saskin

            I didn’t want to give her a hit (Kerry, dear, in web terminology giving a hit means clicking on the page and increasing the number of views, not that I’d like to hit you or anything violent like that. So please don’t contact your imaginary lawyer to sue me, OK?) so I didn’t read it but Kerry being an investigative writer and all, I’m assuming she couldn’t possibly be comparing this season to Adam’s crotch to say that Adam’s crotch is a better singer than all of this year’s kids put together, non?

          • Mithra

            She can have her imaginary lawler come after me then for posting a segment (fair use) :P :

            The Top Ten of American Idol Season 9 performed last night and it is obvious that Adam Lambert, the star of Season 8, has forever transformed the landscape of the most popular show on American television. Tuesday night the stage was packed with Lambert wannabes but it is abundantly clear that no one from Season 9 has the chops to follow Lambert’s footsteps as a rising iconic global superstar.
            Each contestant seems to have a strategy. Use the lighted stairway, a Cajon box drum, change the lighting, sit on a bar stool, change up their hairdo week-by-week or just scream. The screams are what bug me the most. They are more reminiscent of Gokey’s “Scream On” than of Lambert’s perfect-pitched high notes. As the amazing vocalist Kelly Clarkson recently said, it is not about hitting a high note it is about hitting the right note, which seems to escape one particular contestant this year.
            The reason why I bring up the obvious attempts by Season 9 contestants to replicate Lambert’s amazing moments is that while we are suffering through one of the dullest seasons ever on American Idol, the rest of the world is basking in the joy of Adam’s amazing performances overseas. I have heard rumors that Great Britain is offering to exchange Susan Boyle for Adam Lambert. As the people over there see it, if we, in the US, are so puritanical about Adam’s high-octane sexiness, maybe Boyle is more our cup of tea? Boyle will not cause a ruckus at the AMA’s and Adam’s style suits the Brits just fine.
            All I can say is won’t you please come home Adam Lambert?

          • http://topidolblog.com TopIdol

            This is a post about last night’s results show. It would help if we were able to stay SLIGHTLY on topic. This kind of counts, but I don’t want every post to be hijacked into something about Adam Lambert and/or Kerry Kolsch. There are/will be plenty of posts devoted entirely to them.

            But I guess the Glamberts make everything about Adam, so therefore ANYTHING about Idol on the internet becomes about him. hgoeiheuohgurahuiehruheioahgrio

          • Chester

            “But I guess the Glamberts make everything about Adam, so therefore ANYTHING about Idol on the internet becomes about him. ”
            Hmm..Top Idol, I guess that you make everything about Glamberts.

          • ftube2009

            Sorry. I’m guilty of jumping into that sidetrack.

            A side question – Why do some comments not have a reply button?

          • Mithra

            Sorry about posting the link. I thought it was kind of on topic :( and had to do with my theory that this is NOT the worst season but the fantarding was so OTT before that it’s colouring perceptions. Should we just dig up old threads and post then? It’s kind of hard knowing if those are still being posted on.

          • http://topidolblog.com TopIdol

            I woke up with a headache again and worked from home. Perhaps I was being irritable.

            Kerry Kolsch humor is always welcome. I just don’t need every thread diverging into the usual ;)

            Perhaps I should start doing The Daily Kolsch post and feature key excerpts from her book.

          • ftube2009

            I would read The Daily Kolsch religiously. I’m hooked.

          • deez

            Me too…bring the CRAZY. I just checked the comments @ ALSTN. Guess what? They are all positive! She’s either deleted the negative ones, or no one at all has posted there except for sockpuppets. This was my fav:

            9. priscela says:
            March 31, 2010 at 8:27 pm
            adam lambert-kris allen theyre birthyear traits traits naalyzer from the phsychic.
            adam lambert traits;1982
            his traits are
            brave-devoted-warm-hearted-friendly-faithful-loyal-sincere-
            intelligent-talented-imaginative-knowledgeable-modest-calm-sensitive-trustworthy-understanding-unselfish-responsible and idealistic.
            birthmonth capricorn cusp aqaurius- sign of very friendly-genuis human being.
            elvis presley birthyear same as adma lambert;same zodiac sign diffrent birhtyear.
            elvis also was born jan.
            adma january as well hes in the cusp-capricorn aquarius.

            kris allen; gemini cusp cancer-ox year 1985;
            hes biased-chauvenistic-complacent-conservative-dogmatic-easily angered-easily agitated-eccentric-gloomy-hot-tempered-proud-stubborn.
            determined-persistent-serious-consistent-clear thinking.

            WOW. SO ACCURATE. :D

          • Sherena

            Wait are these real? From an actual analyzer?

            ANYWAY, Kris’s traits are pretty awesome, starting from “eccentric” anyway.

            eccentric-gloomy-hot-tempered-proud-stubborn.
            determined-persistent-serious-consistent-clear thinking.

            Pretty powerful kind of personality right there. Passion and reason in one, yum.

          • Sherena

            I SAID ANYWAY TWICE IN THE SAME SENTENCE

            T.T redundancy, I have failed forgive me

          • deez

            Can one be both “complacent” and “determined and persistent?” That doesn’t really sound right, lol.

            The scary thing is that somebody took the time to look up this crap. I mean who puts so much stock in useless internet stats, and mindless ramblings?…. oh wait.

          • et

            Snort. That is actually kinda hilarious. I definitely get the eccentric/hot tempered vibe off Kris and not Adam. *Definitely*

          • deez

            Here’s one of KK’s comments on her article:

            Kerry Kolsch

            03/31/2010@Amy How many performers are doing exactly what was done previously on American idol by Adam? They are using Adam’s type lighting. They are using the stairs and they are using back up vocals and instrumentalist in a way that was not done before Adam. Adam broke new ground and it is obvious that he is being copied. Sometimes it is obvious and sometime it is by nuance as with Big Mike.

            Ummm…Ok? Adam-type-lighting…what is that exactly? No one used the stairs before Adam? Weren’t the stairs debuted just last year? (if I remember right). Back up vocals and instrumentalists not used before Adam? (I don’t remember that either) Big Mike copying Adam? Why, because he was sitting on a stool?
            Somebody should make a list of all the stuff Adam has done in the past so that no one will ever COPY him again!!

            I also liked the last part of that article where she drops the homophobia charges again. We are all PURITANICAL!!

          • http://topidolblog.com TopIdol

            I bet, in Kerry’s world, no other Idol contestant ever performed a song sitting down before.

          • Pandora

            I bet in Kerry’s world, Idol didn’t exist before last season.

          • ftube2009

            @Pandora – She believes the world didn’t exist before Madame.

          • http://topidolblog.com TopIdol

            I want @pandora to also be an Avatard. I love the Avatards.

          • Pandora

            Sorry, “Pandora” is from the music app, not the movie. The movie was OK but I will not tard over anything created by James Cameron. Plus I will not tard over any movie with dialogue that horrible, and a story that was a rip-off of Dancing With Wolves.

          • http://topidolblog.com TopIdol

            Well, its probably a good thing, as the Avatards are scary. Seriously. Google “avatard” and you’ll see ;)

            Side note, Pandora hit over 50 mil users yesterday…

          • margie

            I remember little Archie using the stairs during his season.

          • saskin

            Wow. I was right. She is comparing this season to Adam’s crotch in Japan.

            But I think she is right, I mean everyone is up there singing other peoples songs, on a stage, with lights, dressed, in front of an audience, sitting or walking or dancing, holding a microphone, introduced by Ryan… Adam did all of those things last year before these kids did it this year. And I don’t care weather or not Archie or every contestant that has ever been on this show did those before him. Adam did it before these kids. Period.

          • jukejoint

            D’ya think she knows our Puritans came from England? Better not tell her. It would only confuse her.

          • Claire

            Holy crap! The Season Nine contestants change their hair each week? Wow, could they be more blatantly obvious with their Adam imitation?

            Good Lord, Sanjaya changed his hair up from week to week.

          • Pandora

            Remember, in Kerry’s world Idol itself did not exist before Adam Lambert, therefore any memories of previous contestants have obviously been fabricated.

  • SmartPoptart

    Oh god, when it got down to the bottom 2 I thought who do I root for? The girl whose voice I kind of like when she’s not crying or looking so much like Brooke White its creepy? Or the guy who can’t sing but actually shows some semblance of a personality when he slides across the stage and blatantly laughs in the judges’ faces?! What to do?!

    And then, I decided to root for Tim.

    HOW DID THAT HAPPEN & WHAT IS GOING ON IN THE WORLD!?

  • jukejoint

    I know I’ve worn out the welcome of my AI-goes-in-5-year-cycles thing, but… AI4, which is what I think this one reflects, booted three girls in a row in 12-11-10. (It was Lindsay Cardinale, Mikalah Gordon and Jessica Sierra, and no, I don’t know who they are, either, except I think Mikalah comes back every once in awhile to host somebody’s hometown during the finale.) It was still a girl’s year, and maybe they were clearing away the chaff so Carrie would be the only one getting girl votes?

    Anyway, if the pattern holds, next week a boy gets the boot in the Nikko-Smith-pulled-back-from-the-brink-after-another-guy-left spot. That’s gotta be Tim Urban. I dunno, though. He’s been B2 twice now. Will they let it be that predictable?

    But then, shockingly enough, in season 4, ANOTHER girl left at 8. Nadia. I loved her and her ponyhawk. That left only two girls, and they would end up 1 and 3. Soooo… Maybe we can get rid of Katie in Nadia’s spot, but I think that’s too obvious. We’ll see. So far, the season 4 parallel is holding. Coincidenza?

    • Lauren

      Tim is not leaving. I say we all power-vote for him! Now who has that link to power-voting instructions?

      • jukejoint

        See below for power-voting instructions.

      • Verbally Dyslexic

        Even ontd_ai has decided to go Worster and vote the heck out of Tim. This’ll be awesome!

      • BettyBlue

        The day Tim is voted out will be the day I stop watching AI this season. It won’t be the same without Timmeh!

    • http://topidolblog.com TopIdol

      I still love Nadia Turner. She was just ahead of her time.

      • jukejoint

        No, I’m sorry, Nadia just got in a Chick-Fil-A provided time machine, went to season 8, watched Dambert, and then went back to season 4 with what she learned. Any and all awesomeness was thereby STOLLEN and THEIVIEREED from Dambert.

        No one except Dambert in the history of the universe has ever been pitched-perfect and awesome. I’m sure Cy Young, Don Larsen, Catfish Hunter and Mark Buehrle all pitched perfect after stealing from Dambert, too.

  • RarelyC

    Yes, these contestants have no chemistry together, and it sucks the energy out of the show. No one cares when a person leaves or conveys an ounce of empathy that doesn’t seem staged and forced. And Kara sucks the energy out of the show. That fake Ryan-Simon and intra-judge squabbling is beyond stupid. The judges are all like bloated ticks, hooked onto the rump of American culture. It’s just bad all around — I now record the show so I can skip through most of it just to make my pool picks. And that Siohban is really annoying me — don’t cry when you are safe — that’s pathetic. I have never power voted before, but I will power vote my heart out if it comes down to Siohban and anyone else. (Of course, I have to first have to figure out how to power vote.) Okay, I feel better now. Oh, and another thing — girls’ year is down down to only three girls out of nine contestants.

    • saskin

      That girl is such a brat. I know, BTW, that I am judging her on her personality rather than her singing but since none of them can sing I have to look at their personalities to tell them apart. Soooo; there is the teen witch, the brat and the subway singer to represent females. I don’t think a girl can win this year.

    • jukejoint

      1) Get an AT&T phone with unlimited texting.

      2) As soon as you know the number for the person you want to vote for, store a bunch of messages (the whole message is the word VOTE), each cc’d as many times as possible to the same number.

      3) Save all of those messages as drafts on your phone.

      4) Do #2 as many times as you can stand it.

      5) On the night of voting, two minutes before the show ends, send all those messages you stored. It will take about five minutes and then you can eat nachos and drink margaritas for the rest of the voting period. If you have a kid or a husband you can make push the send button for you, you can skip the sending yourself and go straight to the nachos and margaritas. Or Chick-Fil-A and cheese dip if you are (*gasp*) in Arkansas and beholden to those cheaterhaterhomephobeKristards.

      These instructions were brought to you by Cooktards by way of Archies by way of the Soul Patrol. Have fun!

      • saskin

        Why AT&T?

        • jukejoint

          You can only text with AT&T and you can only power-vote with texting.

          • saskin

            Oh. That sucks. I thought you could text from any provider.

      • Lauren

        I don’t have an AT&T phone. As much as I love you Tim, you are not worth buying a new cell phone.

        • Mithra

          You can power vote without texting. One way is to download dialidol software. The other way is just good old fashioned speed dialing on your cell or landline, or both/all if you can. Just figure the amount of seconds it takes for your phone to connect and the recording starts. Usually 5 to 11 seconds. Hang up. Hit redial. Don’t even bother putting it up to your ear. Sit and watch TV or surf the web.

      • the mighty rose

        http://www.observer-reporter.com/or/hazlettstory/03-29-2010-hazlett-column-american-idol-picks

        and in reply to this article:

        Front runners : 3/29/2010
        Adam Lambert is the most successful Season 8 contestant but that is because he was by far more popular and talented than Kris. I just finished reading the new book out called Adam Lambert Second to None and now I know why Kris could not have won fairly. I know what they did in Arkansas. Matt Jordan and AT&T gave out phones and taught power texting. Adam was not a front runner who lost, he was cheated out of his win and became more successful anyway.

        Corey

        • Claire

          Niiiice.

        • Verbally Dyslexic

          Corey = Kerry? LOL!

          • jukejoint

            Not very imaginative when picking pseudonyms there. Next up will be Kari, Kyrie, Kirie, Korry, Callie, Kelly, Carrie, Cary, Coley, Kippy, Kitty, Kari and Kammy. Or maybe she can branch out into Mary, Larry, Gary, Harry, Terry, Barry, Jerry, Perry and Derry. Watch for their exciting missives all over the internet!

            Yes, you can vote without texting. But you can get in ten times as many votes texting, which is why Kerry thought it was cheating, even though it’s perfectly acceptable by AT&T and AI and the instructions are all over the net. No busy signals. And you don’t have to keep hitting redial because you can send ten or twenty or fifty votes at once, however many cc’s your phone will allow. My current phone (Blackberry) takes 9 ccs, while the one I had when I sent a ton of votes to David Cook during his finale allowed 19. So if I set up 50 drafts, each with 9 ccs attached, I can send 500 votes in the time it takes me to hit send 50 times. Which is about a minute and a half. With Cook, I guess that means I sent a thousand votes — 50 messages, 20 at a time. Huh. That was a lot of votes.

            I don’t have a land line and have never been able to do DialIdol. With a regular phone, hitting redial and getting busies, I’ve never done more than 250. Again, that was Cook’s year, which was the only time I really tried to vote like a crazy person. (I got the AT&T phone for the finale, so was only dialing, not texting, before the finale.) And I plan to never, ever do it again. I just disliked Archie that much.

        • ftube2009

          I posted a polite reply to “Cory” as if I didn’t know it was Kerry. I even apologized for Cory losing her money on buying the “book”. Lets see if the mods approve it.

  • Verbally Dyslexic

    SAAAAAM WORTHINGTOOOOOOOOOONNNNNNN!!!!

    /tard

    • CayKat

      yesssssssssssssssssssssssssss!

  • Nich

    Also Kara’s bitching out Tim got a little uncomfortable. “Do you understand the words we are saying to you?” Yeah, he understands and that’s why he keeps laughing at you all.

    • On The Edge

      Who was that guy in “Rush Hour?” You know, the one who said to Jackie Chan “do you understand the words that are coming out of my mouth?”

      • Verbally Dyslexic

        Chris Tucker, I think.

    • deez

      That was ridiculous! Kara questioning someone’s intelligence? HAHAHAHAHAHA!!!! (Studio 57, Saturday Night Live). Honestly, what’s he supposed to do? Cry? Smiling is about the only thing he can do at this point. He knows he’s on borrowed time here. They keep urging him to “feel” his performances, but I wonder how much life experience this boy actually has.

      His attempts at sexyface (at least I’m assuming that’s what that creepy-eye face was) are all kinds of wrong. His parents should’ve let him go to public school.

      • Sandy

        I think Tim is just doing the best he can. He can’t help it if he is not that talented. He might as well smile his ass off and enjoy it for as long as it lasts. Kara should just STFU.

        • Pandora

          I’m waiting for Tim to say “If you think I suck so much, why did you put me on the show to begin with?” That would be the Idol Moment to end all Moments.

          • naiya

            I have always wanted someone to say that. Maybe VFTW could pool their resources and bribe him.

          • deez

            If he said that…I would actually start voting. (We’re up to top 9 and I still haven’t cared enough to vote this year.)

        • ftube2009

          Half…no…two-thirds of the young entertainers in Hollywood are not that talented. All they need is looks, a good attitude, a squeaky clean image, and willing to do whatever their handlers tell them too. Tim Urban is tailor-made to be a teen idol. Timmeh for the win!!

  • CayKat

    THIS:

    “Is it just me, or do these people all hate each other?”

    Yes they do TI, they most certainly do. It’s palpable.

    • On The Edge

      It always irked Simon that all the contestants got along, as if they weren’t being competitive enough. Well, Simon, you got your wish, they all hate each other. How’s your show doing NOW?

      • Nich

        True! The better the group gets along, the better the season. Look at how none of them really seem to want even be near each other.

        • DeeDee

          Are they living in the idol mansion this year? If so that must be lots of laughs.

          • Verbally Dyslexic

            Maybe that’s why we haven’t seen any glimpse of these guys living together so far.

          • Mithra

            No, I think they are back in the apartments/condos. The mansion was an expensive flop that they rarely used on the show. The whole idea was to show more behind the scenes stuff. All I remember off the top of my head is them jumping in the pool as the top 13, and Gokey molesting Allison in a cake fight.

  • et

    At least Turban amuses me… I was fine with that Bottom 3, only wish they could have all gone tonight…

  • deez

    This show is so done.

  • Kathy

    All I have to say is God Bless VFTW! I am giddy.

    • Lauren

      Me too! My friend and I were talking on FB as they announced that Tim was safe and we both squealed!

  • Nich

    I think in Idol land, “girls year” means “see how fast we can send the majority of girls home”.