I guess this is better than last week? AI9 Top 20 (Girls)
After much drama and rumors of a possible disqualification, right before showtime, it was announced Crystal Bowersox (love her) would perform on tonight’s American Idol.
Because its so unlike American Idol to drag something out. While I would rather see Crystal Bowersox singing on life support than oh, say, 80% of this season’s contestants do anything, I still think Idol took this will she or won’t she game just a wee bit too far over the last 24 hours.
Jesus christ. Bitch better stop this shit. Only Paula can glome onto Simon! I’m THIS CLOSE to calling Kara DioGuardi something that starts with C and rhymes with something you should not to in baseball. THIS CLOSE, DAMMIT. THIS CLOSE.
Crystal Bowersox
As Long As I Can See Light
Crystal is going first! Even though she was hospitalized. She has a twin brother. Brothersox! She said he’s a square. I love you, Crystal Bowersox. Tonight, she’s putting a gospel spin on the Credence Clearwater Revival classic. For someone who was an infirm yesterday, she certainly sounds good. She even makes good use of those pesky backup singers!
Is Crystal missing a tooth? At first, I suspected they made up this whole hospital story in order to give her proper recovery from some crazy dental makeover (see Joanie’s visit to the dentist in ANTM Cycle 6). The plot thickens. Or not. Maybe she lost that tooth a long time ago and anyway, who cares? Crystal Bowersox is awesome.
I wonder if I will sleep better tonight knowing Randy finds truth in reality. He’s a modern-day Nietzsche. Kara DioGuardi proves, once again, why Shit-For-Brains is a more suitable monkier. The bitch said Crystal sang You Oughta Know last week. Uh, no. She sand Hand in My Pocket. Simon busts out the Bush-ism misunderestimate. Dude. But he finishes by comparing her to Kelly Clarkson.
(I feel kind of strange that I stopped the DVR midway through the commercial break in order to see Kris Allen’s Ford commercial. But they’re just so damn endearing and sort of make me want to buy a Ford for a few seconds. If I buy a Ford, will I be awesome in one just like Kris Allen?
Haeley Vaughn
The Climb
Haeley thinks we could not tell she made her headbands all by herself. Homegirl please. Haeley is singing Miley Cyrus, therefore, she is likely to at least be superior to the original. The Climb is a terrible song. Haeley is woefully out of tune. And she said she was going to try and not smile, but its obviously impossible for her, so she should just go with it, I guess.
Yes, the performance was youthful, but dude…it was a bit cringe-worthy. I am almost inclined to agree with Randy when he says excruciating. He doesn’t think she has a connection with the song. No. She does not. Because she was smiling. It’s all about climbing shit, and climbing shit is tough. She really should have worked on squinting a bit more, as to appear she was gritting her teeth.
Lacey Brown
Kiss Me
Lacey likes screwing around with old furniture She does a better job at it than I could, so I’ll give her a couple of points for her little hobby. Sadly, she took Kara DioGuardi’s advice from last week and is now doing Sixpence None The Richer’s Kiss Me (you knew they were a Christian group, right?). If someone is going to sing Kiss Me, they really need to come out in a little red dress or overalls a la Rachel Leigh Cook in She’s All That. Frankly, Kiss Me is a lame song to sing, as it is fairly karaoke. It’s just like in Karaoke Revolution! It so is!
I really like her voice. Or I think I could, but this song, ugh. The arrangement leaves a lot to be desired. The most entertaining part may have been watching Big Mike [Lynche] dancing to it from behind. Oh. And I really would love to know how to duplicate Lacey’s dewy flushed cheeks. Lacey smiles a lot during the song, but it seems more appropriate than her predecessor because the song was about kissing and not climbing.
Is anyone else starting to get angry at Ellen? I sort of just want her to be mean to someone! BE MEAN, ELLEN. BE MEAN! Oh, and in case you were wondering — I don’t see Lacey lasting beyond the Top 16.
(Luke Wilson. What’s up? I’m glad I got to have a few drinks before you arrived this evening. Giggity, giggity. Now lose the blazer.)
Katie Stevens
Put Your Records On
Katie Stevens may look all sweet and innocent, but she doesn’t fool me. She’s a mean girl camoflaged in Aerie clothing. And color me unconvinced she had nothing to do with Miss Bowersox’s recent hospitalization. You know she was pulling some Nomi Malone shit. She also wants us to like her because she can say give me a kiss in six languages…including English. So its not all that impressive.
Megan Joy sang Put Your Records On last year, and I don’t care what any of you haters say. I loved Megan Joy. She was also a better dancer than Katie Stevens. Katie bounces from the knees! That is so not good for her joints. People in the audience look confused, as they’re not sure how to clap. Sure, Katie has a decent voice. Does it blow me away? No. Will we ever see her do anything but sing the song as it was originally recorded? Hell no. We didn’t see David Archuleta do that, either. (And I swear, if I am forced to hear this kid sing Angel, I will cut someone.)
Ellen repeats the mantra about Katie not singing to her age. Well golly gee. Haeley Vaughn did The Climb? What else could she do that was more her age? I tune Shit-for-Brains out because she often makes me want to fling myself out my window. Or fling poo.
Shoot me now. In searching for young artists Katie might like (under 20), Seacrest suggests THE MOPPET OF BEELZEBUB/IMP OF HADES. Yo, Ryan. What is your obsession with that douchebag eunuch?
Didi Benami
Lean On Me
Before Didi hits the stage, she prays. And meows. Oskar is not amused. Didi bugs me. She also is too stupid to know what indulgent means. When I hear she is doing Bill Withers, I got really scared. I thought, no…no…when I said I missed Season 8, I didn’t want you people just to sing songs I heard back then. If Paisley Meow Bitch was gonna sing some Ain’t No Sunshine, I might have been tempted to throw down. Too soon, ya know. (And yes…I already know what Lilly Allen is singing…but I don’t recall that one being rearranged.)
Didi isn’t the worst thing I’ve ever heard, but the song goes NOWHERE. It’s stuck in song purgatory. I think she jumped around on stage. I’ve already forgotten it, except for the dude playing double bass. And while Ellen is the designated nice judge, who can pull random songs/artists out of her ass on occasion, she needs to stop being nice. She has rendered herself completely useless. At least Paula would tell someone they looked nice when they sucked. She actually humors them by commending them on their vocals. I’m almost appreciative of Randy stepping up his game, as no one gives a rat’s ass what Kara has to say, because that bitch just wants to hear herself talk. She also meows. Oh Kara, you are such a c….c…..cu….cougar. Plus, if I said it, I would be disrespecting Scottish slang and every Irvine Welsh book I’ve ever read.
Seacrest wants to caress Didi all night long. And call her his little Bieber.
Michelle Delamor
With Arms Wide Open
Michelle doing a Creed song? That’s almost interesting! This might be the first time Creed has ever been interesting.We all know the only time Creed was a tiny bit cool, and that was for about 60 seconds during the Paul Walker-Joshua Jackson (living in my dream harem alongside Jon Hamm) classic, The Skulls.
Sadly, I could not find the clip I was looking for, you know, the one with Paul and Joshie riding in the speedboat to Skull Island, however, I did find something truly disturbing. And its Idol-related! It’s Clay Aiken!
Michelle directs a little kids’ church choir, therefore, she prays before performing. I think David Cook is the closest thing to an Atheist Idol we’re ever gonna get. I guess it was interesting. Er, more interesting than last week. To be honest, I ended up watching half of the Joshua Jackson tribute video while marveling at just how terrible an artist Clay Aiken is.
Yes, Ellen. We get it. You love almost everyone’s song choices. When Shit-For-Brains starts talking, I want to start punching things. Sure, she’s nice to Michelle. That’s great. It’s her favorite performance to date because it was believable. Yada yada yada. Shut up you stupid, c….c….condescending twat.
Vera Wang is here?
(Giggity…giggity…Luke Wilson. He lost the blazer.)
Lilly Scott
A Change is Gonna Come
Glamberts must be shitting bricks right not, as Lilly is singing Sam Cooke! The same song their savior sang for last year’s finale. Personally, I’m excited to hear a girl [other than CORETTA SCOTT MERCADO] do it. I adore Lilly. She doesn’t pray before she goes out on stage. She uses throat spray. Pragmatism is so much cooler than relying on Jesus.
Could someone tell me why Lilly Scott is even on American Idol? How did she slip through the cracks? This is phenomenal. It’s like an entirely new song. THIS is how you change it up. THIS is how you make something old entirely new again. Gee whiz, this reminds me of when…don’t shoot me, ok? But when Kris Allen sang Ain’t No Sunshine. I’m not discounting Adam Lambert’s finale performance, but I preferred this one because it was a bit more restrained. It was a different take on something sung many times before. Of course, as with most things, nothing compares to the original.
Shut up, Kara. You just suck. She says Lilly just had a moment and that cool people are now going to try out for Idol now, just because they’ve seen Lilly Scott. Simon doesn’t want to love Lilly, so he takes her down a notch, clearly saying he prefers the Bowersox over the Scott. I dunno…I thought Crystal was great, but tonight, Lilly blew EVERYONE out of the water. (And she was wearing a kick ass dress.)
Katelyn Epperly
The Scientist
Katelyn has studied a bit of recording engineering. Good. She has a tiny clue. Last week, Katelyn was a pleasant surprise, leading me to believe I could really end up enjoying her this season. She’s also quite personable in her pre-performance package. Katelyn will also be the first contestant in the semifinals to play the piano, and while Coldplay can sometimes prove disastrous…
Katelyn’s The Scientist starts off strong, not unlike Lady Gaga’s stripped down Poker Face, perhaps? And her voice…it’s not entirely unlike…wow. Once again, I am happily surprised by Katelyn Epperly. She also gets bonus points for something very special. I spy a BABY QUATTO THE MOLE on her head. This can only mean she is blessed.
Did Ellen prepare her notes ahead of time? Guitar? Or was that a joke. So now she chooses to criticize? Too slow? While ballads do put me to sleep on Idol, I thought this was one of the strongest performances of the night.
Paige Miles
Walk Away
Nice SmartWater plug. Sometimes, I like to color, too. No, really. I do.
Paige is not a bad singer, she’s just not…memorable? Again, I do hate it when people do songs by Past Idols on the show. This is also one of Kelly Clarkson’s weakest songs. Its a serviceable rendition, however. Paige has a strong voice. Not so sure about the glory note, nor am I sure she knows who she is as an artist. Perhaps you should show me a coloring book.
No wonder its one of Kelly Clarkson’s weak songs. Kara DioGuardi helped write it! BTW, can I start calling Paige Lisa Turtle now? She totally has a Lark Voorhees vibe about her. Speaking of Kara, she ruins everything. It seems she wrote this about some guy that done her wrong, therefore it should have been ANGRY. ANGRY. I don’t want to know these things about her. Funny, I never thought Kelly Clarkson sounded angry when singing it, either. Kara DioGuardi, you are such a c—.
Siobhan Magnus
Think
Ah, yes. Closing the show with quirky little Siobhan, whose endearing awkwardness and killer fashion sense makes me warm to her a little more each week. She also once had a mohawk. She could be the closest thing Idol has ever had to Lisbeth Salander.
Siobhan shows some serious balls to take on Aretha Franklin’s Think. And this little white girl from Cape Cod is pretty damn good. And holy shit. That glory note. Combined with the fact I adore the faces she makes while singing, well…Siobhan Magnus, I think I kind of love you. I’m even more taken by this week’s performance in comparison to last week’s Wicked Game. One minute, she’s low register. The next minute, she’s going off the charts. Siobhan Magnus is worth watching. Because now I’m wondering what she’s gonna do next.
So who is gonna be sent packing this week? Smart money may be on Lacey and Didi, although I suspect Haeley, Michelle or Katie may also be in danger. Hmmm…what about Paige? Maybe it would be easier if I just said who is NOT going home:
- Lilly Scott
- Crystal Bowersox
- Siobhan Magnus
- Katelyn Epperly (Baby Quatto, I love you.)
But I still kind of miss Season 8, don’t you?











![[Facebook]](http://topidolblog.com/wp-content/plugins/bookmarkify/facebook.png)
![[Google]](http://topidolblog.com/wp-content/plugins/bookmarkify/google.png)
![[Reddit]](http://topidolblog.com/wp-content/plugins/bookmarkify/reddit.png)
![[StumbleUpon]](http://topidolblog.com/wp-content/plugins/bookmarkify/stumbleupon.png)
![[Twitter]](http://topidolblog.com/wp-content/plugins/bookmarkify/twitter.png)
![[Yahoo!]](http://topidolblog.com/wp-content/plugins/bookmarkify/yahoo.png)
![[Email]](http://topidolblog.com/wp-content/plugins/bookmarkify/email.png)



